English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

1- readability in bright sunlight
2- less chance of reading error
3- better accuracy
4- less circuit loading

2006-12-13 05:07:05 · 7 answers · asked by Anonymous in Science & Mathematics Engineering

7 answers

As an electronics technician I would choose a Digital Multimeter (DMM) over an Analogue Multimeter firstly because of the DMM's ability to deliver highly accurate readings in my job I have to adjust circuit voltages to within millivolts and sometimes microvolts, secondly because there is no chance of paralax error as most Analogue meters have a mirror behind the pointer to align it, but most don't have this advantage, it is sometimes difficult to align the pointer to a particular reading because of space constraints therefore making the meter harder to read say from a distance, so that this error can be induced into the reading whereas DMM's don't have this problem. All DMM's have a very large input impedance meaning the meter itself doesn't load down the circuit inducing an inaccurate reading whereas Analogue meter have varying input impedances and if you choose to use an Analogue meter with a low input impedance say less than half a Meg Ohm then you'll induce an unwanted load into the circuit and your readings will be very inaccurate.

In short, I would choose a DMM over an Analogue meter because of Choices 2, 3 and 4. Therefore the answer to your question is choiced 1, As choice 1 is not considered an advantage of a DMM but is one of its drawbacks.

That said a DMM is a very poor choice if you are measuring voltage drops across switches or measuring switch performance, for example switch speed with respect to signal strength. In Aircraft circuitry this function is vital to ensure relay action in the aircraft is positive with no "bounce". This is important in an aircraft situation because you don't want the pilot to be selecting systems by switches which are intermittent.

The best and really the only way to do this accurately is with an Analogue meter as you can actually see the action of the switch happening in real time and measure the resistance of the switch contacts at the same time, very very handy for this function.

Hope that I haven't confused you and that you find this information useful....good luck and a good question....

2006-12-13 05:44:32 · answer #1 · answered by Gaz 5 · 0 0

Absolutely, #1 is the only advantage analog meters have over DMMs.

Re #2, DMMs provide solid numbers rather than a scale that has to be interpreted. Re #3, analog meters are limited to at best, about 1% accuracy, due to the combination of the limits of analog metering circuitry and the limits of interpreting the scale. Re #4, analog meters actually load the circuit under test quite a bit, most that I recall by about 10kohms/V. DMMs, even cheap ones, have input impedances measured in the gigaohm range.

Definitely #1.

2006-12-13 05:27:44 · answer #2 · answered by Gary H 6 · 0 0

2- less chance of reading error

They both should be readable in the light
they both are equally accurate
They both require the same circuit loading

The digital meter will tell you the answer in numbers. The analog meter may require you to pick the right scale and read the numbers from the scale correctly.

2006-12-13 05:14:21 · answer #3 · answered by DanE 7 · 0 0

The answer is readability in bright sunlight. To test this theory, take a calculator or something else with an LED screen outside and see how much more difficult is to read. This isn't that bad of a problem, so LEDs are the standard today (plus they're solid state).

2006-12-13 09:31:48 · answer #4 · answered by JJB1083 1 · 0 0

MA... In some techniques you're top. Any student of physics right now can crack a e book and benefit via employing analyzing some lines what Albert Einstein and Pythagoras sweated blood to come to a decision. Any electrician does understand as plenty approximately electricity as Thomas Edison (i will end wanting announcing Nikola Tesla, the guy replaced right into a Wizard, final analysis) Does this make Joe the electrician a miles better guy than Tesla? infrequently. Does it make xxEmoZipxx from BandP Wristslashers a miles better guitarist that Jimi Hendrix? Hell no, i do no longer care how plenty technically extra beneficial they could play. Mozart, Nikola Tesla, Einsten, Hendrix, they have been Gods. i do no longer provide a raggedy ratstich how plenty extra beneficial somebody right now can replica, they did it first and that's the place the rubber finished met the line to me. Copying isn't comparable to inventing to me. and that i take slightly exception to right now's athletes or in spite of could wreck those of the previous. provide Babe Ruth a bat a placed him up against a sort of juiced up MLB Prima Donnas. he will draw close. Take distinctive the golly whiz fencers we've been given right now provide em a sword and placed em up against Achilles, see who's left bleeding interior the airborne dirt and dust. Heroes are heroes for a reason, they are extra beneficial than existence and that transcends any age or era. MA2; If i'm an fool for admiring greatness and heroes, and questioning we desire extra balls and much less plastic in this limp excuse for an age then i'm an fool proudly. i could extremely be a dinosaur on my ft than a sheep on my knees. (And NO i'm no longer announcing all of us right here's a sheep) BA: extremely yeah, as I stated some people's stature crosses all generations yet for many musicians and entertainers yeah generationalsm has plenty to do with it I[m confident.

2016-12-30 08:47:31 · answer #5 · answered by ? 3 · 0 0

1. In bright light, the LCDs can either fade or be difficult to read. The other 3 functions the DMM has 'hands down'.

2006-12-13 05:16:02 · answer #6 · answered by words_smith_4u 6 · 0 0

2- In certain Instrumentation measurements (eg.mv from certain transducers) involving varying frequencies, the DMM is unreliable...It's circuitry utilizes a fixed frequency reference....However, it can obviously measure frequency itself, if that is what the selector is set to...

2006-12-13 05:39:58 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers