was i wrong to spank her cat?

Question

my friend and her cat are staying with me. her cat is always scratching my things. her cat always scratches my door at night to try to enter. to prevent this,i have tried yelling at him, spraying him with water from a spray bottle(her idea), putting him in his cat carrier and i have spanked him. my friend says i am abusive to animals and she will never forgive me for hitting her cat. she says she heard me hit him and it was hard. i said she should have been controling her cat, however she left it up to me to deal with it. on the 3rd night of dealing with this problem, i spanked him. was i wrong to spank her cat? was she wrong to not do anything and leave it up to me? our friendship has suffered as a result. please reply with yall's opinion

Answer 1

I think your friend is being quite ridiculous because it's not like you maimed the cat or did it for fun. Her cat is HER responsibility, she was wrong in letting it scratch up your stuff and making you deal with it.

Answer 2

Apologize to your friend and really mean it and try to understand her feelings. Say that you won't do it again and you had no idea spanking a cat could be as bad as spanking a child blah blah blah. I love animals to death but I occasionally spank my cats, not hard like I would hit my TV when it's not working but I give them tap them on the head until they get the picture, and then there are the times that I give them a slap on their leg w/ just my fingers not full palm. I think you're friend is overeacting unless you actually did some real damage to the cat then she should get over it soon. In my opinion she should have realized that this was annoying you, it is your house and I wouldn't expect my best friend to put up w/ my cat tearing up the house, I'd be grateful she let me and the cat stay! I don't believe 'spanking' a cat is all that bad, my cat never jumps on my kitchen table and that's how I got him to stop. I'm not home all the time so I'm not comfortable w/ walking around w/ tape on its fur, I know I wouldn't like the feel of someone pulling tape out of my hair so why would I put tape on the places I don't want my cat to be I also don't like spraying him since his favorite place to hide is where all the electrical wires are nor am I going to walk around w/ a water bottle attached to my hip!

Answer 3

Well, considering the fact that spanking a cat will have no effect and will probably cause MORE behavioral problems. I think you were wrong to do it. If you don't want the cat to scratch the door then open it.... I know if I was in the same situation I would be secretly snickering up my sleeve at you for not being able to control a pet without resorting to violence and if it was my cat you smacked I would have slapped you right back. Cats dont learn from corporal punishment it only makes them misbehave more, the people I know who hit their cats ended up with crap on their bed, piss on their clothes, inappropriate aggression and many other problems. If you dont like animals and have no idea how to train them I suggest you dont let pet owners live at your house. Stop letting little things bother you so much and leave your door open at night because no matter what you do one thing that drives cats crazy is a closed door, they always have to see whats on the other side. I bet if you open your door the cat will look around and then leave, or cuddle up to you which is very good for you. People with cats benefit from reduced blood pressure, stress and increased relaxation. If you would take some time to befriend the cat you will gain much more than from hitting it...

Answer 4

Wow...I can't believe some of these answers. If anyone ever smacked one of my cats, I would be LIVID. There's no need to hit a cat ever, a cat is not a child, it does not understand discipline like that. All you did was hurt and scare the cat.

However, I would forgive you. Life's too short, she should be more in control of her own animals, and it seems as if you didn't do it out of hatefulness.

Answer 5

i might propose a scratching positioned up additionally, even though it does no longer stop the project. My cats have a super scratching positioned up, and approximately 5-6 cardboard scratchers crammed with catnip, and one among those AsSeenOnTV Emery Cat scratchers and that they nevertheless insist on scratching the rattling leather-based fixtures (BTW cats love scratching leather-based, that revenues woman replaced right into a liar!). If the cat maintains to scratch and you opt for it to stop you would be able to desire to get claw covers for it incredibly is front paws, or a number of that grotesque stick on sparkling plastic that protects your fixtures (it does not conceal the full element, purely a small section). in my view i've got tried each little thing (confident even swatting their butts) to no avail. A cats gonna scratch what you do no longer opt for it to, except you get it de-clawed, which i believe is advise and inhumane in case you're letting it outdoors. playstation often whilst human beings "spank," their pets they do think of it is going to artwork like it does for people. when I "swat," at my cats butt I yet my hand right into a claw and style of in simple terms jab them gently. Like how the canines Whisper makes use of that technique to stop a canines from misbehaving. Yeah, nevertheless does not artwork, so as that technique replaced into eradicated tremendously with out postpone. maximum folk whilst "spanking," their pets are not hurting them to the element the place its painful, a minimum of optimistically they are not!

Answer 6

If a friend of mine ever hit my cat, I'd never speak to her again. What were you thinking? Are you some kind of control freak? If you didn't like them there, you simply should have asked her to go, but hitting a cat is cruel and could never accomplish anything except you feeling you got some revenge by hitting him. I certainly understand where she is coming from. You should apologise to her and explain that you didn't understand, but if she's a true animal lover your friendship might be over....I could never be the same with a friend again after they did that to my cat, or for that matter, if I saw them do it to any animal. It's not like it was attacking you and you needed to defend yourself. It's a helpless animal for G-d's sake.

Answer 7

Well,she should have put the kitty in the room with her first off!
Secondly..i wouldn't want someone else spanking my kitties.Now if i were staying at someone elses house and my cats weren't listening..Then someone were to have tried everything in their power to make them listen and i was doing nothing...Well,thats another story!
I wouldn't have liked it..but it's their house and their rules .Especially if im doing nothing to stop my animals from bothering them in their home!
I do understand where your coming from here....
I wouldn't let it ruin a friendship though...Get her into her own place..A.S.A.P

Answer 8

i think you had the right to take some kind of action, you just took the wrong action, when a cat starts acting like that your supposed to tap it on the nose, they don't like that and it teaches them discipline. they wont do whatever they were doing before if you tap them firmly on the nose ( but not too hard). i know it sounds stupid but its true, Ive had three cats and my cousins have a zoo of them, it the way your supposed to discipline a cat or dog.

And about you friendship, just explain why you did it, if she doesn't take responsibility for her cat then you should be allowed to take action. maybe you went a little to far but it not completely you fault, i wouldn't say your abusive, your just inexperienced with animals.

Answer 9

Why did you let your friend stay at your place, if you knew that she has an irritating cat? Nevertheless, I think your friend is really a bad guest and obviously hasn't trained her pet well. She could have done something cause it's her cat and she's staying at your place; I would think that's it's common politeness to behave like a good guest. Meaning not letting her cat causing any harm to others.

Answer 10

I would apologize. Then don't have the cats over again. They are like his kids. You wouldn't spank his kids I doubt. Don't know if that is abusvie, I wasn't there. I don't hit my animals, but I will tap their nose if they misbehave. For the sake of the friendship, apologize and let him be right, whehter or not you feel that way.

Answer 11

People are sensitive about their pets. You should have been more assertive with your friend and told her to control her cat. I am aware that my cats are hard to control so I never inflict them on anyone else. Your friend should try to find a more cat friendly place or maybe you can try to make your place more cat friendly.