Are they really illegal ??

Question

To me its incredible that we still havent learned anything from our human history.

Laws are not always justice and right ..... we can see that in history. Slavery used to be legal, everything that tyrans back in the days did was legal. For some people (those living under monarchies) even wanting freedom was a crime.

So please dont come up talking to me about laws. Since the foundation of the earth many laws had been broken for the benefit of a few. And then they again make laws for their benefit.

Laws to me are the ones that benefit everybody, not those that benefit just a few.

And then you call them illegals ... for the reason of not having a documentation you yourself deny them

Every person has the right to eat the bread his hands earns without any persecution.

Answer 1

If you made a market for farm workers for many ,many
years and then decided to close the door and call the ones you trap in with your door "illegal" how could you find any reasonable justification for that as an intelligent being? What would you think of a country that permitted all kinds of weapons to be proliferated within its borders and then decided that any body that had one of those weapons was holding it illegally? As you can see it is easy to criminalize non criminals. Could you kindly tell me how many Americans in Iraq have resident visas?
I guess they are "illegal Iraq invaders"?
Maybe, Afghanistan does not count, either, oh well, it is so easy to pontificate when one is comfortable living as an insentient, self indulgent couch potato. When reality hits and life becomes hard , most of the arrogant spoiled, big mouthed, critical braggarts are the first to beg for mercy, they can sure dish it, but cannot take it.

Answer 2

We are free to love you in your own country. But, yes. You are illegal. If I can't go to Australia and not be kicked the hell out after six months, then YOU sure as sht can't come into America/ Western countries and pretend you are supposed to be here because there is "no such thing as an illegal person". Bullsht.
I would be illegal in Australia, and that is FAIR because THOSE ARE THE DAMN RULES to preserve the well being of a WHOLE COUNTRY.
You have NO Qualms whatsoever that the millions flooding nations brings down the quality of life for ALL and erodes nationalism and stability within nations, not to meantion making the country MORE DANGEROUS for those who are NATIVE to the land. How do you see that as fair?
IF I can't go to live where ever I want, neither can you! What gives you the right and the privilage that I don't have and DON'T dare expect!!?

Answer 3

Uh....I can't tell, are you talking about illegal immigrants? I think so...

You said - "And then you call them illegals ... for the reason of not having a documentation you yourself deny them"

Well, I was married for 18 years to an immigrant who did it LEGALLY. He jumped through the hoops our laws required so that he DID get that documentation. (By the way, our government doesn't DENY it to anyone, unless they have a serious criminal record. They simply require that you apply for it according to the rules.)

My ex gets angry about illegal immigrants. He says, "I had to do it by the rules, so they should have to too." I think he has a good point.

So my question to you is. . . why do some immigrants think they are so much better than others, that they don't have to play by the same rules?

You also said - - "Laws to me are the ones that benefit everybody, not those that benefit just a few."

That's exactly what our immigration laws are meant to do. They speak for the benefit of the majority of America, not just a few immigrants breaking our laws.

Answer 4

As Long As He Isn't Stealing My Flour
And Using My Oven To Bake His Bread





ILLEGAL ALIENS Flood The Labor Market With Cheap Labor
Falsely Depressing Wages

Might As Well Be Stealing My Bread Off Of My Table

Why Must American Citizens
Pay Higher Taxes
To Cover The Cost Of Municipal Services
That ILLEGAL ALIENS Receive

Example ??

We Pay TAXES
To Pay The GARBAGEMAN
To Pick Up Our Trash Twice Each Week

ILLEGAL ALIENS Get Their Trash Picked Up
And They Are Not Paying The Taxes
To Cover The Garbageman's Salary


Hmmm ....

Answer 5

We pay for services for poor people that poor people will never make enough money to pay enough taxes to cover, such as education. Our own children need those education funds. It isn't a piece of paper, it is a judgment that there is room in the system for their family, and that out of all of the families who applied, the legal is the one we want.

We limit immigration of poor people to protect schools and services for our own people. People who legally immigrate have received our approval to be here and their right to those services. The others are stealing them. They have NO RIGHT to do that.

Answer 6

When illegals come here they are taken advantage of by business that hire them usally under the table, no benefits, no raises. This makes it hard for them to suceed, and then the taxpayers have to foot the bill.

Answer 7

The undocumented visitors are not Americans. But the Americans want them to follow American laws. This does sound right at all. America needs to learn and judge undocumented visitors by the laws of Mexico.and the best part is Mexico has no laws about being undocumented in America.

Answer 8

If they want to be legal, they can go back south, there they can be anything they want to. -------------- oh no, another of those humans can not be illegal nuts. ------------ next you'll be saying the old, God made this world for all of us to live any place we want to.

Answer 9

Seems like you are preaching a sermon.What is the question?

Answer 10

Yes they really are .