How can i properly break my 2 year old from her "Binkie"?

Question

My daughter is 2 years old now and she cannot live without her "binkie" pacifier! I have tried making her go "cold turkey" but i just can't take her sad crying! She will cry and throw fits all day long! I know i need to make her give it up! But i want to do it so that it's easy on the both of us! Please help with some positive actions to take to help me help her get rid of the "plug" (which is what me and my husband call it)!

Answer 1

My parents just took it away from my little brother and wouldnt let him have it back, no matter how much he cryed. He would cry all day long. That lasted about two weeks, but by the end of it, he practically didn't even now what a binkie was anymore.

Answer 2

You can also try setting a date and telling her, "Ok, in 2 days, we're giving binkie away to a baby who needs it." That's how my sister in law did it with my niece when she was 2. She "gave" it to her baby cousin when she was born. I do recommend taking it cold turkey, though. Yes, she will be a nightmare for a few days, but then it will be over and no more binkie. Be sure to get rid of all of them and throw them in the trash, so you won't be tempted to give it to her. Make sure that there are plenty of things to distract her and keep her occupied. You can even take her to the store and get her a special cuddling toy that she can use to comfort herself. Let her pick it out herself so that she will know it is special and only let her hold it when she would normally have the binkie. HTH some!!

Answer 3

I just took my sons away 2 nights ago. Yes he has been an utter nightmare with crying and tantrums but I'm glad we have got rid of the "pop" (what he called his dummy) because he is just turned 2 and i was hoping to have got rid of his by a year old but things didn't work out that way.

I know its hard but i think taking it away and letting her go cold turkey is the best way. I know she will cry and cry and you will get really upset but after a week she will not remember it honestly. My son has only been without his dummy for 2 days and doesn't even mention it. When she manages to go a few hours/ few days without it, reward her. Even if your only rewarding her with all your praise, which is probably the best thing. It will give her loads of encouragement.

Good luck!!

Answer 4

Try a huge party for getting rid of it. Make a special event out of saying goodbye to the binkie. Then have her take it to the trash, or better yet, give it to someone as a gift. (they obviously don't keep it.) but that way you can explain to her what happened to it and why she doesn't have it anymore. It might not work this young, but if you can let her have it until around 3 it might work better.

Why are you so worried about her having it still? Its a comfort thing for her, so really consider putting it off for a while. She isn't going to damage her teeth or have it all through her life. She will give it up when She's ready... but that's my opinion...

Answer 5

Sad enough going cold turkey is the only way, don't just take it away throw it away. So long it stays in the house it is an option. and when she cries often you will tend to give it to her to "plug" her. This will teach if she wants all she has to do is cry for it. If it is not there and she cries for it, by not being able to give it to her she will learn that crying for doesn't work anymore and will give up. best to do it when you have a week vacation.

Answer 6

i think of that is common, as long as he's not having sexual relatives with those females. What sixteen 365 days previous boy desires to cool down and get all extreme? i did not understand many while i became into that age. Did you? i might have a verbal replace with him approximately what he's as much as and ask him why he does not pass on a date or 2 with somebody in the previous identifying to "pass secure" with a woman, this variety there is little to no drama.

Answer 7

Never force a child to do something they are not ready to do
Erik Erikson once said a pacifier and a bottle or blanket is precious to a child if you take that away from them they will develop mistrust rather than trust with people just let her have it and let her leave it when she is ready don't weary about what other people will say you daughter will develop better mouth sensation that she needs to prepare her for speech remember a childs first sensation is her mouth since they have no control of the use of their hands

Answer 8

Hey mom...lighten up ....
she is only two!!! You are not talking about a ten year old in diapers, just a 2 yr. old who likes her binkie, jeesse let it go. I am 50, my daughter had hers till she was 4, yes I was upset, she is now a senior in college, perfect teeth, and a very well adjusted individual...
the binkie is better than thumb or finger sucking because it will go away eventually, let it be. My own mom gave me all kinds of shi* about it, but hey, they don't just know everything....
if you take it away she willl want it all the more, she is only two...give her a bit of a break here.

Answer 9

With my son, when he was two we told him he could only have it for naps and bedtime. As he was nearing his 3rd birthday we started talking it up that he was going to put it away forever on his 3rd birthday. We made it sound really exciting and explained that 3 years old is old enough to no longer need one. We showed him where it would go (a box of infant memories). On his 3rd birthday, we had him put it in the box himself. He was reluctant but we coached him through it. He only asked for it the next couple of days. After that, he never asked for it again.

Answer 10

I have three kids myself and I just hat to take theirs away from them even if they cryed. Buy you a nice pair of ear plugs because crying never hurt anybody.