is Islam and the prophet above criticism?

Question

does it mean that we can allow islam to grow without been questioned? this is a question that even most muslims keep asking ?

when i say that nothing in our world today let alone islam is above criticicm, am i right?

Answer 1

OF COURSE NOT!

But it is childishly distastefull to redicule some other faiths prophet.

Your mother isn't above criuticism. I can say my opinion about the food she prepares, or the ay she talks, and I might disagree with most of her opinions. This is freedom of speach as i understand it and you should repsect my opinion, BUT, If I just go along spraying the walls with "I ****** your momma last night " graphiti for no other reason that teasing you, then screaming "Gothca" if you respond, then this is not the rational act of a crtic, this is not freedom of speach. this is pure lack of taste done childishly by an idiot!
Of course if such attitude comes out of a child, it is acceptable, but if it comes out from an adult, supposidly rational, public figure, it becomes atrocious.
Or so i belive.
As a muslim,. I am asked by God to belive in jesus and his teachings, yet if I am ever to disagree with any of such teaching , I would never express this disagreement by insulting Jesus! What purpose would that serve other than hatered?
Peace and love be upon you.Differences shouldn't lead to insults.
It is always easier to express one's oppinion in a civilized manner,Isn't it?

Answer 2

Important Criterion*

[9:24] Proclaim: "If your parents, your children, your siblings, your spouses, your family, the money you have earned, a business you worry about, and the homes you cherish are more beloved to you than GOD and His messenger, and the striving in His cause, then just wait until GOD brings His judgment." GOD does not guide the wicked people.

[9:25] GOD has granted you victory in many situations. But on the day of Hunayn, you became too proud of your great number. Consequently, it did not help you at all, and the spacious earth became so straitened around you, that you turned around and fled.

[9:26] Then GOD sent down contentment upon His messenger and upon the believers. And He sent down invisible soldiers; He thus punished those who disbelieved. This is the requital for the disbelievers.

_____________________________________________________________________
*9:24 Since the odds are overwhelming against any human being to actually believe and devote the worship to God alone (12:103, 106), it is virtually impossible to see a whole family believe. Thus, most believers have been faced with the question: "Either me or God and His messenger." This question is consistently stated by spouses of the believers, or their parents, their children, etc. Consistently, the believers made the right choice. This is a mandatory test for all believers (29:2).

http://www.submission.org/suras/sura9.htm

Answer 3

Ali Sina is an exmuslim that was born and raised as a muslim and was angry that no one would allow him to ask any questions that even hinted anything other his complete agreement with the teachings.

he has a strong challenge for all muslims and if you are a good muslim you should beat him in his challenge and then tell the world about it. he is willing to pay $50,000 to anyone who can prove him wrong.

not suprised that he is now receiving death threats from the religion of peace. visit news.faithfreedom.org and you decide

Answer 4

"what proportion Christian bashing video clips and musicals have been made (final temptation, J. celeb)? All different religions and ideology are regulared roasted, wisely, different than Islam." You do comprehend that (some greater hardcore) Christians call for the boycott of almost each thing that is going against what they have confidence in? they don't all evaluate it good to be roasted, alot of them won't even stand for human beings having a distinctive opinion. Ever heard of the AFA? They boycott many companys that grant reward to comparable intercourse couples (disney, ford automobiles and so on.), they boycott objective attempting to rigidity them into asserting Merry Christmas as adversarial to the greater accepting chuffed holiday journeys. They boycotted NBC and the tutor The e book of Daniel because of the fact the FICTION tutor offended them (many Christian communities called for boycotts until the tutor became into pulled, they could not purely not WATCH IT) Do an elementary Google seek for Christian Boycotts. a very good variety of issues will pop up. issues that are basically basically a differing of evaluations. they are going to attempt to rigidity themselves onto matters that don't subject them in my view. some (extremists) experience it okay to homicide abortion docs and shoot up abortion clinics. we don't choose all Christians by using the strikes and words of a few who react interior the incorrect way. Islam does not proceed to be untouched. I see greater hatred spewed out onto Muslims than I do the different faith (a minimum of recently). this may well be a variety of issues the place i think of all of us desires to benefit. sure, some Muslims could attain that criticism and jokes would be hurled at each faith and that they could cope with that throughout a much less violent way. maximum Muslims understand that reacting in violence does not help anybody. however the media and the information will never concentration on the point headed ones who denounce the strikes of the greater vicious ones. i don't accept as true with leveling violence against human beings basically for words or photos. I additionally do not think of stirring the pot just to rile up Muslims and attempt to anger/insult them helping the placement. all of us could learn and help one yet another pass into the destiny at the same time. Muslim extremists suck. So do Christian extremists. So do any extremists. they have confidence the top justifies the ability.

Answer 5

There must be some grounds on which you want to criticise.
And before criticising one should know all the necessary aspects of that particular thing.
So if you've made your mind to criticise ISLAM..
it's good that at least you're interested.
But i would advice you to first read Qu'ran..
im sure after reading it all your doubts will vanish.
And if there's still anything left, i'm here i'll answer you.

Take Care.

Answer 6

I approached Islam with a critical mind.

I'm still critical about it. But I have to admit, there are no mistakes that I have found yet.

try this:- http://www.irf.net or mail me at [e-mail]

Answer 7

Nothing is above criticism, but you better have strong grounds to criticize anything.

Answer 8

You are wrong in all that you say about Islam. Learn the facts before you spew shlt here.

Answer 9

Al Islam is a religion..... every religion is above critisism ..slander..ridicule....

Answer 10

All religions should be approached with a critical mind. Non of them wants you to because the moment you apply logical thinking they all are exposed as a fraud, read this; http://www.godisimaginary.com/index.htm