Was it reasonable for Israel to use experimental nuclear weapons against Lebanon?

Question

http://www.uruknet.de/?p=m28827&hd=&size=1&l=e

Answer 1

Right. Like I'm gonna believe that website's report.

How about a confirmatory report from a REPUTABLE news service?

Answer 2

The article states that the tests are being run. The Daily Star does not confirm that such a substance was used. While it is known that phosphorus bombs were used in Beirut in the 80's, this claim of radiation is unproven. Are you trying to start WW III? Be careful what you ask for.

Is it welcomed in Lebanon that Hizbollah provokes Israel into attacking time and again? Would the people of Lebanon who are sick of the fighting be better off if Israel had a provisional government run Lebanon and remove Hizbollah permanently?

When is enough enough? Can't the warmongers leave Israel and Lebanon alone to live in peace?

Answer 3

No Israel might basically use nuclear weapons below 2 situations.If nuclear weapons have been makes use of on Israel.If say China joined the Arab international to weigh down Israel.If Israel used nuclear weapons first it may well be completely destroyed in some unspecified time interior the destiny in time.

Answer 4

They didn't. If they had, Lebanon would no longer exist.
1) I have no idea what your website is. I don't even know what the .de extension indicates.
2) Depleted Uranium is not a nuclear weapon & is not experimental.
DU is an anti armor weapon. Since Hezb'allah doesn't have tanks, there is no reason Israel would have used it.

Don't believe something just because it is posted on the internet.

Answer 5

you use a biased sourcs. You are spreading terrorist lies. If Israel acted like you muslims. It would control the middle east. If the usa the USA acted like muslims the middle east would be a nuclear waste land. If care for the futer of you kids you would work for peace. If the muslims get weapons of mass destruction and use them. The world will not care if we nuke you to hell. You see Israel is not perfect. None of us are. We make mistakes. However Israel is willing to stop fighting if you stop attacking them. Why cant you forgive Israel for its mistakes. Cant you see that war will only lead to the death of more people on both sides. Who cares that Israel has a peace of land that once was muslim. They had pormision from the UN to create a country. They will let you use the holy sites. Your stupidity will only lead to more death. Do you wanna teach your kids to hate or to love and forgive?

Answer 6

I have a question here. Who threw the first stone? This whole middle east thing is so tied up in get-evens, it's hard to know where it all started and harder and harder to see where it will end. I still don't see a reason to expose innocent children to radiation, unless it is all out war with survival of an entire civilization at stake.

Answer 7

The Israelis probably bought those munitions from us. I don't have a link handy, you can look it up, but we have been dropping that stuff all over Iraq. Many of our troops have come back from tours having had too much exposure, and are suffering terribly from the effects. Is it reasonable for us or anyone else to do this. I think it is disgusting, but this kind of thing is not new. In Vietnam we used plastic shrapnel so Vietcong field hospitals could not find it with their portable x-ray machines. Why depleted Uranium. You have to ask Dr. Mengele about the reasons for that.

Answer 8

There is nothing unreasonable about dropping a nuke on a Muslim terrorist or on a nation that supports them. Rock on, Israel!!

Answer 9

it is the justice system of the world
Israel uses it its OK, and it is for defence reasons.
If any muslim country just have weapon, it is crime??????

Answer 10

no, never.Thats horrible.That is never justified.
But it probably came from america.