If a tree....?

Question

in the woods falls and no is around, does it make a noise?

Answer 1

Yes.

If you're the only one in the room and you fart, does it smell?

Answer 2

If a tree falls in a forest next to a deaf lumberjack, does it make a noise?

If a tree falls in the forest on top of a mute lumberjack, does he make a noise?

Answer 3

Yes. It is a metaphor. Worry about something more to the point of the season like "Toys for Tots". Maybe you could travel to Walden's woods and have a tree experience.

If a person dies and no one cares, is their contribution to the world worthless? No. All matter, All lives matter.

Answer 4

The tree has to have something to cause it to fall down. There has to be some kind of animal, like a beaver or bear, chewing the trunk or something to cause it to fall over. This just means that there is always some kind of mammal around a tree if it falls over.
but hypothetically, yes, I think it would.

Answer 5

of course. just because we aren't there to witness it doesn't mean that it didn't really happen. it's not like the tree is going to bend down and then lay itself on the ground silently. the force of a tree hitting the ground causes a sound, whether we're there or not. it's like lightning: if it's far away, we can't hear the thunder, but the thunder still happens somewhere else!

Answer 6

Yes- it still makes a sound- ask the creatures in the forest!

Answer 7

Of course. If a traffic light turns red and no one is on the road is it really red ?

Answer 8

ya it will make noise but it will not be accounted,, though it will count as an energy change process..

Answer 9

Obviously, haven't you seen Family Guy?

Answer 10

If a man in talking and there is not a woman there to hear him ... is he still wrong? Of Course!