Do you think it's possible for a person to be suicidal but not mentally ill?

Answer 1

It depends on what you classify as mentally ill. Some people only believe illnesses like schizophrenia are considered 'mental illnesses', whereas depression is not, others consider all forms of depression, anxiety,...to be mental illness. Most suicides are caused by depression or anxiety, so if you believe that these are mental illnesses, then a person probably has to be mentally ill to be suicidal. If you don't think these are illnesses, then a person does not have to be mentally ill to be suicidal.

Answer 2

It all depends on the situation that the person comes from. If some one is suicidal then they need not be judged but helped to over come there feelings of dis-pare. Often a way suicidal people dealing with this problem is to "cut" which many people think that is an attempt to end their life but really is a way to end their emotional pain that is dragging them down by inflicting physical pain to them selves. So the answer to your question is no, mental illness is...undefined.

Answer 3

Yes, even though some experts consider the fact that someone is suicidal is a degree of mental illness.

Answer 4

A suicidal guy or woman stops reasoning to discover thoughts. He/she believes that suicide is the only determination. yet suicide is barely a approach to get away. that isn't the on hand way out considering the shown fact that it factors illness and generally different family members, associates and associates imitate the habit. There are families the place extra that one character dedicated suicide. melancholy, if now not dealt with wisely, might bring about suicide. in case you sense depressed, which you will possibly be able to desire to speak to a healthcare professional, who can competently diagnose your difficulty. it might desire to be that your weight help plan is low in weight loss software D. in case you opt for a supplement, use nutrition D3 because of the fact D2 is produced from petroleum. D3 is from extra beneficial standard supplies. I incredibly have been on all facets, i used to be taking a therapy that made me suicidal, which I provide up taking, and likewise talked 2 men and females into now not committing suicide. i'm completely happy to be alive. i'm now doing my passable to make a difference in persons's lives, via lending a hand, giving encouragement, wearing a grin, or in simple terms being there as quickly as they choose a chum to pay attention. i'm so thrilled i ended the drugs on time. It feels extreme-high quality to help persons and it takes the attention removed from my deepest themes.

Answer 5

generally, suicide is considered to be a form of mental illness. it can stem from depression, or other feelings which originate in the mind. if a person wishes to seek help from suicidal feelings, they need to talk to other people and find ways to make life happier. unfortunately, for me it's a "been there, done that" story. i know first hand what it is like to be stuck in that terrible place. i can only thank that i had so much support from other people.

Answer 6

I believe the answer is yes. Situational depression can be very intense....the question is do you have a "plan"? If you have a plan you should really get some help ASAP....if you are just having "I want to die" feelings that is called suicidal ideation and I believe that everyone gets that at some point in their life....

Answer 7

Nope, the fact that you are suicidal means that you are mentally ill.

Answer 8

definitely..my boyfriend committed suicide by hanging himself in his apt. 2 years ago..he was very depresse yet he masked his feelings with a smile..come to find out that he would be asking randome suicidal questions to his friends, like; "do you think this fan could hold the weight of my body"? no one took him serious because he was a good church-going guy, who always smiled? He began to distance himself from me, so i just thought that a s a guy he needed some time alone, biggest mistake of my life? People tellme it was premeditated, but i cant fatham something like that being premed? he made his phone calls to family a wk prior to the act, he paid bk loans to friends, etc? and stopped talking to me..he loved me? why would he stop talking to me? I found him the first of the month in his apt. i found him hanging..i cant ever get that image out of my head, and i will always feel partially responsible for life because i couldnt help him?

always take suicide seriously...and dont take yourself out of hte equation ever? never give space, that was my mistake?

due to financial difficulty with his business..he was tired of being broke all the time--i miss him dearly

Answer 9

No. Anyone who feels the need to end their life has issues about coping with life and is therefore, unstable which is a mental problem.

Answer 10

no,suicidal thoughts are not normal.it is a sign of depression,feeling so hopeless that the only way out is suicide.see a doctor so you can be put on medication.