Does the Second Law of Thermodynamics prove the existence of God?

Answer 1

I think god proves the second law of thermodynamics

Ob1

Answer 2

Before I begin, I would like to clarify one thing. What counts as proof? Logical proof for the existence of God or actual confirmation on the existence of God? I will just stick to the former; rather than latter because latter is probably beyond anyone's capability.

In a nutshell, this is what 2nd law of thermodyanmics is all about: if you take care of your house (putting energy), then your house will be well maintained, but if you don't put energy to take care of it, the house will eventually deteriorate. Or in short, from something complex to something simpler.

If you are asked who made the 2nd law of thermodynamics, you will not directly find the answer to that question anywhere in the 2nd law of thermodynamics. A scientist who is an atheist may be inclined to reply that that's just the way it is; or even candidly say no one has ever made it. The further question is how did he/she arrive to that particular assertion that no one made it? Such an assertion is quite often presented without any evidence. 2nd law of thermodynamics itself would do nothing to back up that assertion as the law is just there and it is not about how it came into existence or what.

So, the assertion that no one made it is just as good as the opposing assertion that God made it. In other words, the 2nd law of thermodynamics alone would neither prove or disprove the existence of God.

Answer 3

Actually the second law of thermodynamics would prove that God, if he did exist, would eventually die. This law basically says that everything complex will eventually degrade to a simpler form. And God, as commonly defined, is as complex as they come. Either God is mortal (which is self-defeating), or the 2nd law disproves him.

Answer 4

Actually the second law of thermodynamics would prove that God,
if he did exist, would eventually die.
This law basically says that everything complex
will eventually degrade to a simpler form.
And God, as commonly defined, is as complex as they come.
Either God is mortal (which is self-defeating), or the 2nd law disproves him.
====================
/ Houston, we have a problem/
====================
My opinion is another.
It is logical that everything develops from simple form to complex one.
Therefore I think the God exist in very simple absolute referens system ,
in Nothing, Emptiness, Vacuum :T=0K.
From this system ( T=0K) the God,
using his physical and mathematical laws,
created all MATERIAL WORLD .
If somebody doubt that from cold Vacuum T=0K
the heat stars, the hot MATERIAL WORLD can be created,
please, remember that The Second law of thermodynamics
does not forbid this possibility.
=====================
http://www.socratus.com

Answer 5

Just the opposite if you ask me. But what do I know - I'm a Thermodynamic Engineer.

Answer 6

Is this question coming from an answer to a question that you posted earlier?

I would actually like to see an argument in support of this question.
Though I don't see how it would be possible I wouldn't certainly like to see someone try it.

Answer 7

Negatory, from order to disorder, the irreversible trend to utter death and annihilation of the universe.

Answer 8

No, do you know what Thermodynamics is?

Answer 9

Well how about the law of bio that says "Life comes from life"???

Answer 10

No. What would a statistical description of heat phenomena have to do with spiritual beings?