Who do I start Reggie Wayne or Andre Johnson, I can only start one of them?

Question

Who should I start Wayne agaist Tenn? or Johnson agaist Oakland?

Answer 1

Now THAT is a tough call. You will be in good shape starting either, but I'd lean towards starting Andre. There are many more weapons at Indy that will take away from Reggie's production. Honestly, Andre is a must start each week because he's leading the league in receiving yards. Carr may be inconsistent at times, but somehow finds Andre quite a bit.

Answer 2

Go with Wayne. Manning has clearly been targeting him the last few weeks, he seems to be the #1 option for Manning, especially in the red zone. I believe that Johnson is dealing with an injury and is not 100%. Plus Carr's #'s have been falling the last few games, where Manning is pretty consistant. The icing is that Manning is playing against a Tennessee D that is not very good and Johnson is playing against the Raiders, even though their record doesn't reflect it, has been playing pretty tough D this year

Answer 3

Two good receivers for sure. I'd go Wayne for the simple fact that you just don't know what your going to get from Carr from week to week. We know what we are going to get from Peyton and Tenn can't stop the passing game. Also, Reggie has been Peyton's favorite target over the past few weeks since that Denver game. You can't go wrong with either one, but I'd go with Reggie Wayne. Good luck this week.

Answer 4

Go with Reggie Wayne. Oakland seems to be tring to play better on D and give Carr and Houston some problems.

Manning is a better QB so Tennesee shouldnt give him man problems, so go with Regiie Wayne

Answer 5

i would start andre johnson over reggie because oakland at cover anyone he will have a big game

Answer 6

Both are great! I would go wit Reggie Wayne

Answer 7

Wayne vs. Tennessee is a good matchup for colts fans, and manning harisson wayne and rhodes fans.