immigrants?

Question

my grandma once told me that when she was young she came as an immigrant over here and that migration promised her to give her resindence if she told them who passed her over here she did and she did get her reci dency but now shes mexican again. now they still do this. if you were in this situation would you have told them who brought you? do you think what she did was rite? i want sum opinions or answers

SHE LEFT THEY DIDNT TAKE IT AWAY

Answer 1

I would have done exactly what your grandma did. I would have been talking for days if necessary. You see that way they can catch the men that are bringing the immigrants over here. Those people that bring immigrants here, rape the women and kill their men sometimes. It is not that I am for immigrants coming over the border, but it is just that I see both sides of the situation, and I think if they can catch those people, the United States and also the immigrants would be safer. My opinion and nothing else.

Answer 2

She did what she thought was right to do at the time. I myself would have never told. Why is she Mexican again? I would like to know did they take the residency away or what? Did she go back on her own? Let me know!

Answer 3

The world was a different place 90 years ago, so you cannot ask how it will work out today

Answer 4

she was right. and it is wrong for them to take it back. she has been here for so long. they should leave your grandma alone. she probably don't have much time left. she depends on her family to take care of her. i say this because she is an elderly person.