Was Jesus a sinner for breaking the sabbath and allowing his disciples to break the sabbath too?

Question

I keep hearing from christians that the sabbath is a "Day for the Lord", but Jesus says (when caught breaking the sabbath) that the sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath.. so which is it?

Was Jesus just being an artful dodger when caught red handed?

Answer 1

Jesus is lord. the sabbath was so men would not work seven days a week, and get sick and die, from not getting enough rest.

Answer 2

Jesus never broke the Sabbath. No Bible verse states that He ever did. Jesus kept the Sabbath in a way that conflicted with man-made traditions concerning the Sabbath.

Jesus' disciples never broke the Sabbath. No Bible verse states that they ever did.

Since Jesus nor His disciples ever broke the Sabbath according to the Bible, then the answer to your question is a double no; Jesus was not a sinner and Jesus did not break the Sabbath.

Show N Tell

Answer 3

No because he said he is Lord over the Sabbath Day also because he invented it. He was basically saying it was okay to feed yourself or do anything good on the Sabbath. It was made for man in that it is a day for us to rest which everybody needs to function at our maximum.

Answer 4

each of the gospels was written for a specific audience and with a particular author point of view. In order for the gospel to have "authority" it was expressed that the gospel was written by a particular disciple.

there were more than 4 gospels, it was just decided there could only be four, just like the 4 winds, the 4 corners of the earth, etc.

Anyway, this particular story was written by a gentile for the gentile audience and was part of the anti-jew stories as Christianity began to separate itself from the Jewish religion.

Try to find the story where Jesus states, I came to fulfil the law, not to destroy it. It is not in this gospel. Contradictory, huh.

Answer 5

If your employer gives you Sunday's off, and you decide you want to work on Sunday, what's the harm?

Jesus said, man was not created to serve the Sabbath, the sabbath was created to serve (help) Man.

God simply gave us a day off. Holy does not mean religious, it means clean. Clean from obligations.

The Sabbath is a gift to the working person.

If I give you a gift, you can choose to do what you want with it. Why? Because it now belongs to you.

If some Sunday you want to Work, so what? As long as it is voluntary and not forced on you by your employer.

Answer 6

Jesus has authority over the sabbath.

Answer 7

No, Sabbath observation are for the Jews under Mosaic Law. it is time for them to observe spiritual matters.

Jesus (and us) are not under the Mosaic Law.

Jesus said: “My Father has kept working until now, and I keep working.” (John 5:17) Jesus was not performing secular work in order to enrich himself. Rather, he was doing the will of God. Just as the Levites were allowed to continue their sacred service on the Sabbath, Jesus could rightfully carry out his God-assigned duties as the Messiah without violating God’s Law.—Matthew 12:5.

Answer 8

From what i comprehend they in many situations omitted the introduction of a clean personality contained in the thoughts until eventually numerous hundred years after he became invented because he did not fulfill such various of prophecies that were to take position in the course of the existence of the anticipated messiah: * The Sanhedrin will be re-known (Isaiah a million:26) * once he's King, leaders of alternative countries will seem to him for training. (Isaiah 2:4) * the total international will worship the only God of Israel (Isaiah 2:17) * he will be descended from King David (Isaiah eleven:a million) with the help of King Solomon (a million Chron. 22:8-10) * The Moshiach will be a guy of this international, an observant Jew with "concern of God" (Isaiah eleven:2) * Evil and tyranny is in simple terms unable to face earlier his administration (Isaiah eleven:4) * information of God will fill the international (Isaiah eleven:9) * he will comprise and entice people from all cultures and countries (Isaiah eleven:10) * All Israelites will be again to their native land (Isaiah eleven:12) * lack of existence will be swallowed up invariably (Isaiah 25:8) * there'll be no extra starvation or ailment, and lack of existence will end (Isaiah 25:8) * each and every of the lifeless will upward push back (Isaiah 26:19) * The Jewish people will experience eternal excitement and gladness (Isaiah fifty one:eleven) * he will be a messenger of peace (Isaiah 52:7) * countries will finally end up recognizing the wrongs they did to Israel (Isaiah 52:13-fifty 3:5) * The peoples of the international will turn to the Jews for religious training (Zechariah 8:23) * The ruined cities of Israel will be restored (Ezekiel 16:fifty 5) * guns of warfare will be destroyed (Ezekiel 39:9) * The Temple will be rebuilt (Ezekiel 40) resuming lots of the suspended mitzvot * he will then proper the total international to serve God mutually (Zephaniah 3:9) * Jews will comprehend the Torah without study (Jeremiah 31:33) * he will provide you with each and every of the desires of your heart (Psalms 37:4) * he will take the barren land and make it important and fruitful (Isaiah fifty one:3, Amos 9:13-15, Ezekiel 36:29-30, Isaiah eleven:6-9)

Answer 9

Jesus Christ is Lord of the sabbath...

Answer 10

No it was a choice they were given; which was more valuable the Sabbath or a soul(s)?

To use a similar analogy; if one's spouse or child is in serious need of medical attention; should one obey the 20 MPH speed limit sign along the way?