is mental illness just a cop out excuse in life today?

Answer 1

For some it is very real and is a real illness but there are some that use it for a cop out, they say they did something because they have a mental illness when they really don't.

Answer 2

Of course Not.

Mental Illness is no different than physical Illness.

During a persons life time, they will experience some level of Mental Illness. Depression, Anxiety and certain behavior problems.

The treatment of Mental health disorders has made great strides in the past few years. Many Myths have been dispelled concerning Mental Illness disorders.

People are no longer considered Touched today, as they were years ago.

Winston Churchill suffered from Chronic Depression.

Mike Wallace, The 60 Minutes Anchor, suffered a near fatal depression.

Can any one argue that repeated exposure to Combat in war can produce a delayed Post traumatic syndrome disorder.

If you are asking, if anyone has ever used Mental Health issues as an excuse...sure. No different than some person using a Physical problem as an excuse.

But, we all know that excuses only last a short time.

Good Luck to you.

Answer 3

Well..if it is truly mental illness...it really isn't a cop out..but there are also borderline personality traits, stemming from abusive childhoods..which, should always be considered in the way people act when they grow up...sure, a person who has been emotionally truamitized, abused, neglected, etc..can't be expected to deal in society as a person who has enjoyed a stable invironment..on the other hand...a person who is truly mentally ill...could come from the best of homes, and still not be able to function...so no, true mental illness isn't a cop out excuse..it is the reason.

Answer 4

Hmmm...some may use it as a "cop out" to rationalize or explain away such things as aggressive or violent behavior, when in fact there really is no such condition that contributes to it...only a good psychiatrist can properly diagnose if in fact there is a mental illness at work, and would be able to identify in fact what kind of illness it is.

One has to look at the individual holistically, in biopsychosocial terms, to get a tip off as to the extent to which their illness played a part in the behavior in question...look at things like family of origin (Did family members have the condition? early trauma? poverty?)at what age did the person get it? how soon after did they get treatment, if any? What environmental circumstances were at work in this person's life, that may have contributed to the person's decline?

Each person has to be evaluated on a case by case basis. In some cases you'll have people who really are truly/gravely ill, (which sometimes are the ones who are incapable of thoughtfully carrying out a criminal act), and you'll have some who successfully "blame it on their illness" which unfortunately gives a bad rap to the truly mentally ill.

To sum up, mental illness can be a contributing factor in some behaviors we don't generally condone, to the extent that the person can be rendered "not responsible" for the action because he is incapable of rational thought. For example, a paranoid, psychotic person who thinks (wrongfully) that someone is "plotting against him" and decides he needs to take a pre-emptive strike to avoid personal harm. In this case the person REALLY believes that the other person is out to get him, just as sure as the chair I'm sitting on right now.

Answer 5

I use to once think it was until I started to suffer from Severe Anxiety in my early 20's. Having said that, I have not used this illness as an excuse to stop living, living is just harder for me then your average person, your mind is always on an internal rampage but I still have a very successful career, a girlfriend, a home, I workout so I basically live a normal life.

Answer 6

Mental illness is very real but i personally have trouble believing when people say it. My father commited suicide when i was 10 and when my friends in high school found out one in particular would always tell me she was going to slit her wrists, then she told me she did, and when i saw her the next week she was completely markless and had clearly firgot she told me that the week before. I now have alot of trouble believing that others are ill. The problem is it is so widely known now that everyone says it. It may not be a cop out, it may unfortunately be a trend....

Answer 7

No I don't think so. I do think that a big population of people are being diagnose wrong with a mental illness. When really they probably just need some counseling sessions & work out some issues. Not be diagnosed with a mental illness.

Answer 8

Mental illness is a disease. It is now getting the attention it deserves. In fact, mental health will effect your physical health more than or just as much as any physical illness. Who wants to live a life with no JOY, no HOPE, feeling WORTHLESS. I would rather have a physical problem. Just because you cannot touch depression does not mean that it does not exist.

Answer 9

No! Mental illnesses are imbalances in the brain. Some of them are caused by traumatic experiences that you dont know how to deal with. Try looking for books in your local Library about it..it will help you to better understand.

Answer 10

easily everyone could have episodes the position they're out of wide awake administration. a large style of the time, we do not make the information. The courtroom equipment and docs truly artwork at comparing those who've committed crimes. The fakers are many times weeded out. The fairly loopy won't be able to be held to blame. they might want to be locked away and if there is help for them, they deserve a probability. some are previous fix. unhappy. genuine. C. :)!!