is suicide really that selfish?

Question

i dont think that suicide is as selfish as people make it out to be...most things that people do nowadays is for themselves so if a person feels as though its there time to leave then why is this selfish when they are only doing what they really want to do? okay i know it is a truely HORRIBLE thing for familys and friends to have to deal with in the aftermath but they have to think of what that person had to be going through to actually kill themselves....i am truely sorry if this question offends anybody or if anybody had to deal with the aftermath themselves...

Answer 1

I'm going to assume you're the person thinking about suicide so I don't have to clarify each time I'm talking about the person thinking about killing themselves.
--
My best friend killed himself just over 6 years ago now.
He must have been in terrible pain to do something like this. I never saw it coming. Let me just say this. He caused everyone who knew him this same pain. Is this what you want to do to your loved ones? Do you want to be the cause of them suffering? There's help out there you know. You need to bear the burden so others don't have to do it for you. We never get over it. I'll never understand why he did it. I'll let you answer your own question with my question.
Is causing all who care about you to suffer, selfish?
.

Answer 2

Perhaps some suicides could be considered selfish. Maybe a suicide in which a person is seeking revenge against someone they feel has wronged them. Of course, such a person is obviously misguided and probably has some serious mental health issues. The bottom line is that suicide comes down to a split-second decision. Sure, people think about it and even plan it, but excepting certain methods, it only takes a split-second to carry through. Unlike other mistakes, it can't be undone.

I think the pervasive feeling that most people have regarding suicide, when they aren't clouded by emotion, is that of sympathy toward the victim. The victim felt an unbearable pain, felt trapped, with no hope, and made a rash decision.

I feel obligated to note that this is an ethnocentric view of suicide. It is viewed differently in all cultures. In Japan, dating back to samurai ritual suicides, the act is still considered honorable by many.

Answer 3

No I don't think of suicide as selfish. It takes a lot of courage for a person to take his or her own life. It is probably a lot easier to kill another person than to kill yourself. Yeah it does turn the family upside down because of the shock and horror of knowing your loved one is gone. You're right about what the person must have been going through. It's very hard for people to understand what was going on in the mind of the suicide
because most of the people who really intend to kill themselves don't talk about it or threaten and lots don't even leave a note. My brother committed suicide 20 years ago. I mostly blamed myself for not having been able to see what was going on with him. But no I never considered it to be a selfish act. I do miss him a great deal though because he was a wonderful bother.
LL

Answer 4

Yes, it is selfish. It is one of the ultimate selfish acts. It is all about you and you leave family, job, expenses, and friends and responsibilities behind for others to deal with. We all have a time to go but that is not of our choosing. You have no idea what you are missing out on if you just end your life. Life sucks at times but it is always worth living...even if you feel at the time it isn't because everything is relative...what seems horrible today may just be something you learn from and realize wasn't so bad in the future.

Answer 5

Who says that the person committing suicide even HAS loved ones? Not everyone does. Sometimes it's the family itself that drives someone to commit suicide. So, would it then be more selfish for the person living in agony to kill themselves and end the pain, or more selfish for the family to want to keep someone alive who is miserable?

It's the same issue with putting animals to sleep. Why do you do it? So they stop hurting. For humans, though, there's the extra problem of mental health. If they're in so much pain, is it kinder or cruel to let them live?

If you want to do something with YOUR life, no one can or should stop you. It's selfish for people to think they have a say in it.

Answer 6

The only reason that suicide should be used is for hospice reasons.
All the rest of them are mearly wasting what time they have left that could be turned around and used for good.
Feel like commiting suicide?
Go somewhere that makes your problems not so &*^% bad.
Because, there is 'always' someone out there that is doing worse.
Anybody can 'off' themselves...but it takes some real 'hard cores' to make it all the way to the end. Try making it.

Answer 7

Suicide is a final act of cruelty for many people. They plan out their death in order to cause pain to the other poeple who have hurt them in some way. They think of it as a way of getting back at someone & they are actually being quite selfish by taking their own life, rather than dealing with the harshness of reality called LIFE! Unfortunately, only the selfish ones live to tell about it because they were too gutless to go through with it & now they get to be called martyrs! Personally, I view attemped suicide as being more selfish than an actual act of successful suicide. When a person dies, they are no longer in a state of pain & mental anguish. When they live with yet, another failure in their life, it is far worse then if they would have just been able to complete their original task.

Answer 8

YES, ABSOLUTELY!! Suicide is the MOST selfish thing anyone could ever do (or think about doing). I lost my dad to suicide & contemplated it myself, but learned the hard way that God is the ONLY One Who decides when it's time to go on... You're right, family & friends do suffer the aftermath, undescribeable pain. However, as I am learning, this life is only as a grain of sand on the beach of eternity. Check out http://www.gotquestions.org for more info about suicide.

Answer 9

i'm surely doing a paper in this and believe Susan. by definition, sure, suicide is selfish, yet so is the desiring of someone suicidal to stay because you pick them too. no longer them. they are burnt out and they pick to die. each and every aspect are excessively thinking themselves truly than the different get mutually ensuing in a paradox of selfishness and showing how no human being in this international is truly selfish no remember how 'worrying' they warfare to come back off by saving someone off a ledge and telling them they have extra to stay for. Do you imagine they hadn't seen that? Hadn't idea about what extra the international had to provide them? interior united statesa., ninety % of persons who dedicate suicide struggle through from psychological complications that cripple the logical idea procedure, which could synthesise information incorrectly into logical fallacies telling them they are burden and by no ability reliable adequate. commonly, someone who's suicidal has seen everyone it is going to result and has got here to the right that they are going to be forgotten, the international will bypass on, and/or that those human beings will purely be extra useful off with out them.

Answer 10

I have a couple of sets of answers.
Just in case you or someone you know is considering it, I'm going to go on the compassionate side.
The most crass thing I'm going to say, first, is that Nature selects out the messed up genes, so if the potential auto-victim has no kids, then an end to misery for one is ultimately the end to misery for most involved.
Now, unless the person is about to die anyway, is a child molester, or so medically and mentally challenged that life really is impossible and just causes burdens on society,
Yes, suicide is VERY selfish.
And the person even thinking about it better not have kids.