If the U.S Government kicked out all the illegal aliens,what would happen to the economy and how many decades?

Question

would it take for it to find willing low budget white folks to fill those jobs.

I guess they have to think about it real hard, that is why they have not acted to enforce immigration laws.

3dfarms,

Are you a member of the KKK

Answer 1

You Got That Backwards, Chico

The Question Should Be
"what would happen to MEXICOS economy ?? "

The Knife Is NOT At The Throat Of The USA

The US Economy Will NOT COLLAPSE
When 20 Million ILLEGAL ALIENS
Are Unceremoniously DEPORTED

WHEN The ILLEGAL ALIENS Are Deported
And The Border Is Secure
The Nation Of MEXICO Will Suffer The Effects
Tenfold More Than The USA

The MEXICAN ECONOMY Will Fall To Its KNEES






What Do YOU Think Will Happen ??

20 Million ILLEGAL ALIENS
Represent 5 Percent Of The US Worforce
And Roughly 6 Percent Of The Population
A Drop In The Bucket When Compared To
300 Million TAXPAYING Citizens

300 Million HARDWORKING, TAXPAYING CONSUMERS
Support The US Economy
Not 20 Million Nontaxpaying ILLEGAL ALIENS

And What Do YOU Think Will Happen

When Those 20 Million Are Repatriated To Mexico ??
The Mexican Economy Will Have 20 Million More Mouths To Feed

And What Do YOU Think Will Happen

When Those 20 Million Are Repatriated To Mexico
And Some 40 Billion Annually In Remittances
STOP Coming Into Mexicos Economy ??

Remittances From ILLEGAL ALIENS Living In The USA
Is The Nation Of Mexicos Second Largest Source Of Income
2nd Only To Mexicos Oil Export Revenues




So ....

What Do YOU Think Will Happen To MEXICOS Economy
When We Repatriate 20 Million Mexican Citizens




Greenspan Is An IDIOT

.

Answer 2

Actually, we've become really proficient at farming over the last several decades, you really need to get out more.

The stereotypical migrant mexican farm worker has become an icon of the past, although there are many mexican citizens that do participate in american agriculture, there's just as many farms that rely more on automation, and better equipment, to do the same amount of work in, say, half the time. I'm for exploring ways to bring automation, as in robotics, more heavily into the agricultural process. If they can tell what a fly had for breakfast on mars, then they can build a machine that can harvest an apple.

Mexico needs to get with the times, and start doing more for themselves, instead of milking the United States to fulfill all their economic needs. Game's over, turn the lights on, get a job, and stop harping about america. If it hadn't been for american generosity, there's quite a few countries around the world that would've probably starved out and died by now.

Also, immigration laws are now being enforced more frequently.
Businesses that hire illegal aliens and are discovered doing it are being reported, taken to court, fined, and in some cases, shut down altogether.

There's no magic spell that'll take care of 20 years of enforcement negligence, but reform is typically difficult and hard to reason out. Give it time, and the whole immigration mess will be resolved. All 50 states are giving this one some serious thought, now, and from that I think we'll eventually see a lot better policy evolve. Pro-Mexico people should be taking copious notes, with an eye to pushing for better reforms in their own country.
I think Mexico should do some foreign aid 'down the line' as it were, they've got a 1 trillion dollar GDP, now, time for em to 'pay it forward' and help their southern neighbors etc. We've supported em long enough, they can get out there and trade with the rest of the world, instead of 90% of their business just being with the United States etc.

Brave new world we live in, study the numbers for yourself, and
support the US Border Patrol!

Answer 3

If this happened, a Guest Worker program would have to be implimented to accomidate the needs of employers and to keep the economy going. This would greatly increase government revenues by the way, as illegals enjoy many benefits of our government without paying taxes. (Over his or her time in the states, the average illegal is estimated to COST the federal government a minimum of $50,000.)

Answer 4

The U.S. economy will do just fine. We will no longer be paying out billions of dollars in welfare and medicaid to all of the ILLEGAL ALIENS who are not entitled to receive it in the first place.

Answer 5

The economy of this great nation would prosper once again and crime would be at an all time low. All the LEGAL residents could converse and understand one another without a bunch of "Spanglo chatter and jibber-jabber" interrupting the peace.....What a lovely thought..........Thanks for asking!

Answer 6

Wages would go up and the economy would thrive. Unskilled laborers in the US would get their much deserved jobs back.

Answer 7

Since you say they make no money that issue is solved. Whatever job openings there are people will adapt. Not much of a problem

Answer 8

Kick them out and kick the welfare out simultaneously and the jobs will be simultaneously replaced, with the economy being instantly improved!

Answer 9

Get it out of your head. Our economy is not dependant on illegals. Thats just another rich man's propaganda scare tactic.

Answer 10

We'd have the U S A back that I grew up in, and I remenber how nice it was.