Should I stll buy a gift for my 5 year old son that I know my mother in law already bought.?

Question

This is the 1st x-mas my son has asked 4 something specific & has been talking about it for months. He tells everyone in sight. I was planning on getting him the gift from us. I intentionally left it off his lists to grandparents & others. My mother in law informs me on thanksgiving that she went & bought it. I didn't know what to say. I was shocked. She says every year what she is going to get my boys so we don't buy the same things. Trouble is, she never buys what she says & then the boys don't have it. She has dissapointed them year after year. Myself included. I can't tell her to take it back b/c then I'd hurt her feelings. I can't tell her we already bought it b/c we haven't. It's my fault for not buying the gift when he said he wanted it but I'm a habitually late shopper. I'll shop on the 23rd this year. Should I buy him the gift like I planned & then he'll already have it? I probably will no matter what you say, I just want to hear everyone's opinion.

Answer 1

I was going to say no until I read the part about her never buying what she says. You can always take the duplicate gift back if she really bought one

Answer 2

here is my question to you. why didnt you just tell evryone that this gift was something that you had planned on getting for him. being that you new he was telling everyone.so, you plan on doing this no matter what anyone says ok.i always try to be nice when answering a question on here, but this time im making an exception.you said that your mother in law said she already bought it, yet she also says she has bought things only to find out that she didnt. well when she told she bought it thanksgiving,why didnt you ask to see it? so this way you would know for sure.and you say that you cant ask her to take it back because you dont want to hurt her feelings. what a bunch of bull!! but you have no problem going out getting the same thing, giving it to him knowing she said she bought it. you dont think thats going to hurt her feelings? what will you say when she ask why you bought it after she told you she did? { i bought it because i was not sure you were telling the truth about buying it and i did not want to hurt your feeling by asking you to take it back because this was something i wanted to buy for him } to avoid anyone being hurt. why not go to the inlaws the night before, if she did get it for him. then great. if not then you know to put the gift under the tree. then her feelings are not hurt by you buying the same gift she told you she bought, and he will have what he asked for no matter who it was from.

Answer 3

Are you sure your mother in law already bought it? You said she never gets what she said she will. If you are sure she got it though, then i suggest you get him something else. Ask him what else he would like. Or if that specific gift he wanted has an additional item to go with it, you can get that. Whats the point of him having the same gift twice.

Answer 4

erm..well,I think no matter what has happened u should buy Ur son a gift..it's b'coz there isn't any harm if ur son receives the same presents.. U may buy what ur son likes or figure sth out ur-self..Btw,who doesn't like to have gift? don't let ur mother-in-law influences ur thoughts..just go n do what u want.. I'm sure that ur son will be happy if he receives the gift from u..Good luck!

Answer 5

I say sure, i might. She continues to be your son's mom and it would be significant to him to accomplish that. i'm happy which you and your companion are being civil with one yet another. this is unquestionably what's ultimate on your little boy and additionally you the two are doing the astonishing element. whilst your son grows up he will think of back to all of those circumstances you inspired him to be a good son to his mom in spite of a divorce. incredibly in a worldwide the place you spot maximum of divorced households that are so hateful to a minimum of one yet another. I extend my hand and pat you the two on the back! thank you to flow! :)

Answer 6

praise the lord & buy the gift, but save the reciept , just in case.

Answer 7

i would buy it! I had an issue like that with my daughters grandmother.It was like she was trying to upstage me? Weird.........but yes since he wakes up with you on Xmas, and will open those presents first, yes please do us all the favor and buy it. For all the mother's out there that have to deal with their mother-in-laws that are way to over bearing! Merry Xmas to you and your family!

Answer 8

I bought from http://www.luxurysell.net/

http://www.luxurysell.net