The site of the Kabaa in Saudia Arabia was inhabited by two Jewish tribes should Jews enforce their claims?

Question

Muhammed massacred two Jewish tribes that refused to convert that lived near the Kabaa in Saudia Arabia. Should the Israeli government mount a military campaign to reclaim that site or force the Saudia Government to allow Jews safe access to that place. Muhammed forced a Jewish girl from one of those tribes to marry him and kept her in concubine status against her will. She had the courage not to give up her religion to her Arab captor.

One of the Jewish tribes that Mohammed murdered was called the Qurayzah. He surrounded their village and than executed all the men. He could not stand that they refused to give up their beliefs for his made up religion.

Answer 1

EXCELLENT POINT!!!

Jewish tribes used to inhabit the whole of Saudi Arabia until the ethnic cleansing of the Islamists. Clearly Jews have a claim to the land they were wrongfully stripped and murdered of.

Ah yes, but the savage Islamists still scream tha JewJewJewJewrusalem is theirs. Isnt it amazing.

Answer 2

You astonish me. Palestine is the Holy Land to two billion Christians and almost as many Muslims and you feel only one group somehow has an exclusive claim,that being one of the world's smallest religions and in this case one that has erected a brutal militaristic society largely consisting of Russian atheists? There are only 6-7 million real Jews on earth and another five or six self-identified "jews" who actually reject Judaism totally and you think this legitimizes an exclusive claim based on ethnic cleansing? You have got to be from the deep south to think like that. What to speak of seriously thinking that any Arab state would collaborate with an effort to force out the Palestinians from their own country.

Answer 3

Wow Becky...u know so many things....its almost like u were there. I wonder when the phonecians will reclaim everything that the jews took from them...including both their land and their religion. Oh wait, they can't! Because the imaginary man upstairs told his imaginary chose people that they can kill everyone. I keep forgetting that the imaginary chosen people have a special bond w/ the imaginary man upstairs....which entitles them to reclaim the whole universe...all planets and the black hole...the sun...moon...stars...EVERYTHING. Just leave us the pepperoni pizzas, hot dogs, and burgers. We gentiles..or lesser beings need our sustenance.

Answer 4

why do we want that pile of sand?

lets make a deal we wont complain about the tribes of Mecca and Medina not to mention the over 700,000 Jews that were expelled from Arab nations in the last 50 years and you will take the 1.5 Million Palestinians in the west bank to Saudi Arabia. We will even pay you to take them.

Deal?

Answer 5

Honey get your story straight. Mohammed's great great grandfather Qusayy was the keeper of the kabba in the year 400 c.e. He was also the leader of the largest tribe of Mecca- the Quraysh. He is the one who established the six offices of the Kabba- the maintenance and gaurdianship of the keys, the provision of fresh water and food to pilgrims, the leaders of army (Qiyadah) and the holders of the flag of war (Liwa).

Prior to Qussay being leader The Jurham tribe was taken over by the tribe of Khuza-ah. Mohammed's tribe was the lead of Mecca five generations before he was born!

Qusayy also established the house of Government in Mecca (Nadwah).

His forefathers were all keepers of the Kabba. His grandfather Abd al Muttalib even restored the Zam Z am well, which was truly an excellent feat!

Mohammed saved the Kabba from Pagan idolatry and you are saying that the Isreali government should reclaim it?

I think that is absolutely insane. I just dont get that mentality.

As for the captive of war- Safiyya bint Hayayy-- He freed her before he married her and she did indeed embrace Islam. They were only married four years before he died and yet she remained a Muslim until her death at 60 years of age. She was 21 when he died and Islam suffered when Mohammed died- even the Quraysh muslims began to back off from the faith at the time until the first caliph Abu Bakr told them "Mohammed may be dead= but God never dies. It is not Mohammed you worship--- it is God you worship." Even during the struggles of Muslims she remained Muslim. She died and was buried a muslim. Peace be upon her. Isreali's don't own everything. I think they've laid claim to enough Arab land as it is.

Answer 6

First of all, where did you get your information from. It was in Madinah (the city of the prophet) where 2 jewish tribes lived but they lived in peace with the Muslims. Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him) did not force any jewish girl to marry him and change her religion!!! He had a jewish wife who willingly married him and became a Muslimah!

Is your question trying to target hate at Muslims or do you not know the truth about Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)'s nature?

Answer 7

Prophet Muhammad's Constitution of State as Protection and Muslim and Jewish unity and peace.

“In the name of Allah (The One True God) the Compassionate, the Merciful. This is a document from Muhammad, the Prophet, governing the relation between the Believers from among the Qurayshites (i.e., Emigrants from Mecca) and Yathribites (i.e., the residents of Medina) and those who followed them and joined them and strived with them. They form one and the same community as against the rest of men.

“No Believer shall oppose the client of another Believer. Whosoever is rebellious, or seeks to spread injustice, enmity or sedition among the Believers, the hand of every man shall be against him, even if he be a son of one of them. A Believer shall not kill a Believer in retaliation of an unbeliever, nor shall he help an unbeliever against a Believer.

*******“Whosoever among the Jews follows us shall have help and equality; they shall not be injured nor shall any enemy be aided against them.... No separate peace will be made when the Believers are fighting in the way of Allah.... The Believers shall avenge the blood of one another shed in the way of Allah ....Whosoever kills a Believer wrongfully shall be liable to retaliation; all the Believers shall be against him as one man and they are bound to take action against him.

Answer 8

Muhammad slaughtered those Jewish tribes.

Answer 9

please stop your tribal war. According to history the tribes lived in Medina and it is like 200 Miles away from Kabaa.

Answer 10

The Day is coming when there will be neither Saudi Arabia, or Mecca. The Kaaba will be grounded into dust. At the return of Messiah Jesus !