Why is this joke funny?

Question

Here's the joke:

A wealthy man parked his brand new Porche in front of his yacht club, ready to show it off to his friends.

Just as he got out of the car, an truck passed too close and ripped the door off

When the police arrive the man does nothing except scream hysterically about how he just bought his car just a day earlier, and now it was totally ruined.

When he finally calmed down from his ranting, the cop said: "I can't believe how materialistic you are! Don't you notice that your left arm is missing from the elbow down? It must have been torn off when the truck hit you."

"Oh my God!" screamed the man. "Where's my Rolex?"

Now ask yourself: Why is this joke funny?

While you consider this question, here's another version:

A poor man parked the used 1983 Honda he just bought in front of his job at the Wal-Mart.

Just as he got out of the car, an SUV, passed too close and ripped the door off.

When the police arrive the man does nothing except scream hysterically about how he just bought his car just a day earlier, and now it was totally ruined.

When he finally calmed down from his ranting, the cop said: "I can't believe how materialistic you are! Don't you notice that your left arm is missing from the elbow down? It must have been torn off when the SUV hit you."

"Oh my God!" screamed the man. "Where's my Caseo?"

Is this second joke funny?

Personally, I don't think so because it's the story of a weak man getting kicked down, and being misunderstood by the police. Whereas the first one is about a vain man getting his comeuppance.

I'm curious what you think.

Answer 1

The first is funnier, as greed and materialism is always a good humor point.

But I would build up the punch line better.

"Oh, my God! I can;t believe it's missing! Where's my Rolex?"

Answer 2

This first one is definitely funny, I actually know someone who did something similar a few years ago. My friends were involved in a car wreck and when they got out to see the damage, one of the girls didn't ask if anyone was hurt, she said, "Has anyone seen my 2-way?" It's how some people think when they have lots of valuable stuff, they're not worried about things that matter but rather, things that don't matter. It sounds like something that Paris Hilton would say and do also. The 2nd joke really isn't funny because the guy has cheap stuff, a Honda, a Casio, come on! His car and watch and a year of his Wal-Mart paychecks still don't add up to the value of a Porsche.

Answer 3

the first joke is funnier cuz the rich man is more worried about his rolex and his porche than his arm even tho it is the same sinereo as the second man only in a different time period. the second man is more woried about his caseo and 1983 honda than his arm as well, it is as if he is stuk in the 80's and is still just as materialistic as the first man but not as wealthy

Answer 4

you comprehend you're a Redneck even as... a million. you're taking your canines for a walk and also you both use a similar tree. 2. you could entertain your self for better than quarter-hour with a fly swatter. 3. Your boat has no longer left the driveway in 15 years. 4. You burn your backyard truly than mow it. 5. you imagine "The Nutcracker" is something you do off the severe dive. 6. The Salvation military declines your fixtures. 7. You provide to provide someone the blouse off your decrease back and they don't pick it. 8. you've the community taxidermist on % dial. 9. you come back decrease back from the promote off with better than you took. 10. you save a can of Raid on the kitchen table. 11. Your spouse can climb a tree swifter than your cat. 12. Your grandmother has "ammo" on her Christmas record. 13. you save flea and tick cleansing soap contained in the bathe. 14. you've been thinking a custody strive against over a searching canines. 15. You bypass to the inventory motor vehicle races and do not desire a application. 16. you comprehend the way many bales of hay your motor vehicle will carry. 17. you've a rag for a gas cap. 18. your position doesn't have curtains, yet your truck does. 19. You ask your self how service stations save their restroom's so sparkling. 20. you could spit with out starting your mouth. 21. you concentrate on your vehicle plate personalised because your father made it. 22. Your lifetime purpose is to personal a fireworks stand. 23. you've an finished set of salad bowls and that all of them say "Cool Whip" on the aspect. 24. the most important city you have ever been to is Walmart. 25. Your operating television sits on perfect of your non-operating television. 26. you've used your ironing board as a buffet table. 27. A tornado hits your community and does $100,000 properly worth of advancements. 28. you've used a rest room brush to scratch your decrease back. 29. You neglected your fifth grade commencement because you've been on jury duty. 30. you imagine quick foodstuff is hitting a deer at sixty 5. 31. in the adventure that your spouse and youngsters tree doesn't branch.....

Answer 5

The first one has more details of finer life like a porche and a yacht. While the second one didn't have as nice things. So I think the 1st was more materialistic because he had nicer things

Answer 6

Isn't it just representative that a person of modest means can still be materialistic? But I agree, it's not all that funny.

Answer 7

Yes !! Very carefully analysed the situation and the Joke and put down your Comments ! I fully agree with you ! Jokes always go well with Rich, mean and Miser men and not with modest and men with miseries !!! Good One !!!

Answer 8

yea.....i think you are right.
When you read about something like that happening to a rich,vain man it makes sense and it makes you laugh, coz you know that he's probably a b*st*rd.
But,when you read about a poor man,who probably has a lot of problems in his life....just makes you sad and see the injustice in the world.

Answer 9

What is a Rolex and Caseo?

Answer 10

yeah
i agree wit u
the first man was proud
while i have pitty on the second one