Don't you agree that the comparison between Guantanamo and Auschwitz get closer and closer every day?

Question

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061120/ap_on_re_la_am_ca/guantanamo_heart_procedure

By that I mean we are just trying to save his life and give him a better life. The doctors at Auschwitz and other concentration camps performed medical "operations" on the Jews every day. The Nazis did everything from performing brain surgery WITHOUT putting the patient to sleep, to seeing how long a person could survive in freezing temperatures, to bone transplant EXPERIMENTS.

http://www.deathcamps.info/Experiments/experiments.htm

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Holocaust/medpictoc.html

I hope you are intelligent enough to know the definition of "irony" and "satire".

Answer 1

Yes, I know the definition.
.....And the Japs also experimented with our soldiers they had captured. Horrible experiments trying to make biological weapons, and other tortures.
And they didn't get healthy 5 meals a day, prayer time, and reclining chairs like the terrorists a Gitmo.

Answer 2

No, I don't agree.

Comparing a US detention camp to Auschwitz is revolting and unfair.

Sorry about not reading the articles, but I've been burned here following links in the past.

Answer 3

Well, the lunatic leftist rhetoric tries to make them indistinguishable, which is a gross distortion of the truth and a defamation of the US and the US military. They need to apologize to the Holocaust victims for their ill-advised choice of trying to equate captured terrorists with innocent Jews.

Every single person that attempts to equate the treatment of terrorists prisoners in Gitmo - with full dietary fare, medical and sanitation facilities, full religious rights, safe and sanitary living quarters, access to lawyers, etc - with the treatment of Jews in concentration camps - starvation diets, no sanitation, crowded living quarters, torture, sexual abuse, and industrialized murder - should be bitchslapped multiple times for being such a freaking idiot.

Answer 4

Oh, I may have marbles enough to recognize irony and satire, but I also know good and poor taste and indiscretion when I see them. Perhaps you can tell me how many thousands have been gassed and cremated at Gitmo? Also, I hate even the hint of revisionists history or the embellishment of fact or using either in hyperbole. Sorry, this is a ridiculous analogy no matter how it is couched. Please put a check mark in one of your brain cells (You do have one, right?), and refrain from this type of freedom of expression in the future.

Answer 5

No, Auschwitz was a killing ground and innocent Vitim's of hate. Guantanamo is holding killers and terrorists who would like to put you in a Auschwitz were they could torture and kill you. There is a Big difference

Answer 6

How ignorant are you? THERE is now way to compare the two!
The place in Germany KILLED the Jewish people and in Gitmo they are treated better than those in U.S. prisons.
Satire and irony is NOT something you mess with when it comes to these acts by the Nazis.

Answer 7

Stupid.

The biggest difference is that the abuses at Auschwitz actually occurred.

The 'abuses' at Gitmo only exist in your imagination.

Let me guess you mindlessly believe all the claims about Gitmo - and also claim that you 'support the troops' - right? (Notice the hypocrisy here?)

Answer 8

Sure because we are killing the enemy combatants with gas and other chemicals. then burning thier bodies in a giant furnace.yea h your right it is. by the way pigs fly out of my a** while singing the national anthem. man your a dumb mother f*cker

Answer 9

I think the US must do whatever it takes to get info - we are at war..just wish these tactics were also being used on illegals!

Answer 10

Absolutely NOT