Who is the sinner here?

Question

Mav watched a little of Dr 90210 this morning, and they had on this woman who admitted to be addicted to plastic surgery.
She is scheduled to have yet another procedure.

Is she the sinner or is the Doctor a sinner for not cutting her off the 'drug'?

Answer 1

They are both sinners. No one is perfect.

Answer 2

NON of the above Sinner is when you do something bad knowing. Like Still, adultery, Want to be with the girlfriend of your best friend. That is sinner.

The surgery is a personal matter and the drug is only available for a period time maximun 7 days.

Answer 3

A better use of time might be to study the Word and pray or visit the sick or those in prison don't you think? T.V. is not spiritual but carnal (I watched enough before God saved me to make that right judgment!) God will decide who the sinner is although we may see obvious signs of other folks fruits. What good will it do to wonder about it if we cannot possibly reach either the woman or the Doctor to personally witness to them their need for Jesus Christ?? There's a lot of things in this world people do to fulfil the longing in their hearts as well as those who prey and profit on such. We should pray for them but make sure before casting any stones we don't have any sins ourselves.

Answer 4

They are both sinners because 1. Plastic surgerey is wrong, God created us all beautifully so the docter shouldnt be preforming these procedures and 2. the woman shouldnt be having this done.
But we are all sinners and no one but God has the right to judge us.

Answer 5

Okay, if you're asking is " Plastic Surgery a Sin " the answer is " No "
I suppose you could reach into the "coveting they neighbors goods " one and accuse the doctor of that.

From a certain point of view, he was taking advantage of the woman's addiction to acquire her wealth. It something that needs God's wisdom to decipher for certain, but that's this mortals point of view.

Answer 6

For better answers, I would've left "sin" out of it and asked something like, who is responsible.... in that case I would say, she is, and its her body, her decisions, etc. The doc could have refused to do anymore procedures on her and that may have even been the "right" thing to do; however she would have then just found another doctor who would want her business and money, and another and another... if she has the money and desire for it, she would get it done no matter what.

Answer 7

First off, I don't believe in sin. But it could be argued that they are both sinners. Vanity (her addiction) is considered a sin by many, and the Dr enabling her addiction could be seen as a sin as well.

Answer 8

Mav,

I think you may be forgetting that their are two ways of speaking about sin. One is the description of the long-term illness, and the other is in reference to the symptoms of that illness, individual "sins"

Remember, no matter what symptoms they may be exibiting at any one point, they are both sinners.

Answer 9

Mav,
She is sick. The Doctor is the Doctor is The Sinner.

Answer 10

sadly these people should be getting a different type of help ...
help to love themself for who they are
there is obviously deep rooted problems with these people , when they believe they are not good enough ....
i dont feel in this case it is a sin for the woman ( who sees herself as ugly ) ... i do feel the doctors do this because there is demand for it , but more so for the money involved ...
i believe plastic surgery should be kept for those people who have disfigurements ... not for vanity

so if there is a sin here ... it is greed ( of the doctor )

Answer 11

My personal belief is that the doctor has a moral obligation to try to discourage the woman from having any more surgeries, and to refer her to a Psychiatrist.