Can a person be anti-Israel, and NOT be anti-Semitic?

Answer 1

Theoretically if u criticize Israel or Israel's policies you are not antisemitic .You just disagree with the way things are done in there...this doesn't make you racist...unfortunately ,in real life if you are anti Israel you will automatically be labeled as an anti semitic...or even terrorist...

Answer 2

In theory, yes.

In practice, a lot of what gets passed around as anti-Israeli is a currently-acceptable form of anti-Semitism. The very language says something -- have you ever heard the terms anti-Iranian, anti-British, anti-Korean? Even anti-American isn't as common.

Somehow Israel is held to a different standard. It's the only country in the world who has to continually justify and defend its right to exist.

Keep in mind whenever you're reading or listening to this that many Arab and Muslim nations will do anything and everything they can to remove the state of Israel from the planet permanently. This is about old hatreds. This is also about a land grab, at least for Syria who would love a Mediterranean port amongst other things. This is about the Arab League using Palestinian Arabs as pawns for 50 years in order to undermine Israel.

Let Israel exist. And then we can talk about what it's done badly.

Answer 3

Well to begin with, Arabs (some of whom are Christian), Armenians, and some other non-jewish groups are themselves SEMITES so the term has often been inaccurate as something only identifying Jews. And many Jews are not even Semites if they are not sephardic descent. But I digress.

There are many Jewish groups who oppose zionism and the Israeli state. Jewish people are not a monolithic entity that share a common agenda, no matter how much both the conspiracy bigots AND the zionists would have it be.

Answer 4

Sure. You can hate what the nation of Israel is doing but still love semitic people. People all over the globe are proving that its possible to hate the actions of the USA but not feel racist about white people.

Answer 5

Taxing people critical of Israel's policies of anti-semitism is an easy and very cheap trick used by the crook and dishonest to avoid criticism.

Answer 6

Yes. The state of Isreal is just that - a nation-state. Anti-Semitic implies you're anti-Jew, anti-Judaism. I like Jewish people a lot. I don't like Isreal, their government, or the way OUR government bends over backwards to help them with no regard for anyone else. A great many of our foreign policy problems have a direct link to our friendship with Isreal.

Answer 7

the toddler is blatently anti semitic and anti israel !!! i'm hoping your suggested his vile comments !! what a surprising individual hes gonna advance as much as be... i dont comprehend how previous this toddler became yet while he became plenty decrease than the age of 12 identity say hes greater possibly only repeating parrot vogue stuff hes heard his mom and dad say or that hes considered on the internet... to be straightforward nonetheless - his rants dont sound plenty differant to the countless property you get on yahoo... only is going to coach the minds of a few human beings... In my innovations - to be anti israel is a political difficulty -- it ability which you're against the two some or all of Israels movements or its exisitance as a us of a in the way that it got here approximately 60 years in the past... on the comparable time recognising that the jewish human beings do have a connection with that land.. you would be of any back floor or faith and be anti israel in terms of politics... to be anti semitic is to hate or dislike somebody in effortless terms because of the fact they're jewish .. be them a convert, non secular or non coaching... its additionally to have self belief that each and every physique jews are controling the media , banks etc, or that we've not have been given any declare to israel or that we arent perfect jews because of the fact we are all khazars etc im specific you comprehend the stuff.... i think of this toddler falls into the anti semitic catagory greater suitable than the anti Israel one - he doesnt sound like hes sufficiently previous to truly understand the politics of the completed difficulty... in case you may - identity attempt to talk to this toddler and locate out the basis of his themes and hatred... greater suitable than possibly its come from his mom and dad, church or lifestyle frequently... youd be bowled over how the main tolerant human beings on the outdoors are the main racist under... attempt to describe and teach him the differance between jews and israel...yet in spite of you do - dont submit with any destiny rantings - particularly if hes previous enought to comprehend greater proper... if hes no longer keen to take heed to - only shop away yet arise for your self too and dont take to any extent further crapp... bear in mind that what is going on in Israel isn't justification EVER EVER for hating on us jews or for giving us abuse... and that toddler needs to learn that... Buddha suggested that folk hate and lash out while they're suffering.. so in case you may attempt to experience sorry for this toddler and his mom and dad.... wish that enables ?

Answer 8

Sure, disagreement with the policies of a country doesn't mean you are religiously discriminatory. That would be kind of like people who say those that have criticisms of the Iraq war are unpatriotic. The two things don't necessarily go hand in hand.

Answer 9

Yes. I'm anti Israel only in the sense that NO RELIGION should EVER be allowed to have their own state, let alone nuclear weapons. This would extend to The Vatican too.

Answer 10

Semite are people that are from the line of Shem... this includes Israelis and Arabs. So if you like Arabs and not Jews... YES!