Why did John the Baptist deny that he was Elijah....christians or anyone else?

Question

When Jesus said that he was!Well Jesus never said so directly, i think.I can only remember that Jesus said that "Elijah has already come..".His apostles then assumed it to be Elijah. (correct me if I'm wrong).

But If Jesus directly said that John is "Elijah" then why did John deny it?

Sydy nim: Very goo, however Jews never believed in reincarnation.The were waiting for a "Elijah" like figure. John obviously knew this still why did he deny it?

Answer 1

Elijah never died. He did return on the Mount of Transfiguration with Moses. There Peter, James and John witnessed Heavenly Father declare that Jesus was His son.

Answer 2

I did a search about this question and here's what I found. I've included the link from the source at the bottom.

Q: Does the Bible teach reincarnation?



A: No. Scripture teaches that "it is appointed that men die once, and after this comes judgment" (Heb. 9:27). There is absolutely no biblical evidence for reincarnation.

Sometimes people try to find biblical warrant for reincarnation in Christ's words about John the Baptist. In Matthew 17:12 Christ says, "I tell you Elijah has already come, and they did not recognize him." Matthew adds, "Then the disciples understood that he was speaking to them of John the Baptist" (Matt. 17:13).

Is Jesus saying that John was the reincarnation of Elijah? No. Here's the simple reason. According to 2 Kings 2:9-18, Elijah was taken up bodily into heaven without seeing death. Thus, he wasn't a candidate for reincarnation because he was still in his original incarnation.

In Matthew 17:1-8 Moses and Elijah appear to Christ and some of his disciples at the Transfiguration. This occurs after John the Baptist has been executed by Herod Antipas. Why is it, then, that Moses and Elijah appear to Christ and his disciples, and not Moses and John the Baptist?

If Christ doesn't mean John the Baptist is the reincarnation of Elijah, what does he mean? Jesus is speaking figuratively in Matthew17:12. He's comparing the prophetic ministry of John in the New Testament to that of Elijah in the Old. Similarly, Luke 1:17 says John "will go before him [the Lord] in the spirit and power of Elijah."

So there's no biblical basis for reincarnation. A person who is considering reincarnation is faced with a choice of believing other alleged sources of religious truth or believing the biblical witness. To accept the former in this instance is to reject the latter.

Answer 3

John and Elijah where two different people.
Before John baptized Jesus, people thought that he was the savor, but John told them he was not and then when he saw Jesus he said "Behold! The Lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world.

Elijah was the man of God who preached to many. Elijah was also the only man that God sent a firey chariot to take him to heaven.

You can find Elijah in 2 Kings 1:1 - 2:18, and you can find John in John 1:6 - most of the new testament.

Answer 4

in the same way that Jesus was the second ADAM. the Bible uses the term and idea of 'types' quite oftenI will give a different examle that also explains why this happened.
Jesus said that the Girl was not dead, but sleeping, and then the Bible clearly states that she WAS dead.
Contradiction?
Possibly, but no. point of view and definition of terms explains both quite well, in a sense of god looking at us and the view of physical death being a type of sleep until the resurrection, she was both dead and asleep. in like manner, John the Baptist was Elijah, in type, but not Elijah the prophet of old, as it is appointed for man once to die and then the judgment ( AHHH but Elijah did not die, but was taken away and John was born many, many years later, so even reincarnation could not answer how he could be Elijah, if, indeed it meant that he was the Prophet of old).

Answer 5

John denied be Elijah because he wasn't, He was how ever an Elias. Someone who comes to prepare the way. Has Joseph Smith is for the Second Coming

Answer 6

Jesus never said John was Elijah.

John said he was not Elijah because he was not.

Answer 7

i don't have faith why those super prophets might desire to be in contradiction one yet another. that's probably no longer ensue! how come John the Baptist became into in contradiction with Jesus Christ? Jesus suggested if John the Baptist became into Elijah yet John the Baptist denied being Elijah. certainly one of two (Jesus and John) is forbidden by God precise? seem what Jesus Christ suggested approximately John the Baptist: "extremely I inform you, between those born of ladies human beings there has no longer risen all of us greater desirable than John the Baptist! yet he who's least contained in the dominion of heaven is larger than he...!" (Matthew 11:11) i'm a muslim and John the Baptist in Islam is observed as by Yahya (PBUH), and we in no way suggested if John The Baptist became into in super lie. yet i'm attracted to that query at John a million:21 and please do no longer shrink the full question from John a million:19. "And that's the testimony of John while the Jews despatched clergymen and Levites to him from Jerusalem to ask him, who're you? He confessed (admitted the actuality) and did no longer attempt to cover it, yet regarded, i'm no longer the Christ! (in my handbook e book CEV 2001 suggested messiah) They asked him, What then? Are you Elijah? And he suggested, i'm no longer! Are you the Prophet? And he responded, No!" From those verses, extremely we knew there are 3 (3) question to John The Baptist: a. who're you? (meant are you Messiah?) - he suggested i'm no longer the Christ b. Are you Elijah? - he suggested no and Jesus suggested that extremely Elijah has already come, yet they (Jews) did no longer recognize him! c. Are you the Prophet? he responded, no! the tip of those 3 (3) question is: Jews is waiting for the final touch of those 3 (3) needless to say 'prediction' or prophecy, and please do no longer make assumption with those verses, because it became into stated needless to say and we are able to soak up by our recommendations... a million. the arriving of Messia (Jesus Christ) 2. the arriving of Elijah (no physique recognize him) 3. The prophet. If we are clever, then we would desire to take a seem on the footnote from this verse that shall communicate over with Deuteronomy 18:18, who's prophet like (Moses)? And... we would desire to ensure if the prophet might desire to be like Moses yet no longer from Israeli (seem at Deuteronomy 34:10). "And there arose no longer a prophet when you consider that in Israel like Moses, whom the Lord knew head to head...."

Answer 8

Is this the passage that you are referring to?
John 1:19-22 This was the testimony of John when the Jewish leaders sent priests and Temple assistants from Jerusalem to ask John whether he claimed to be the Messiah. He flatly denied it. "I am not the Messiah " he said. "Well then who are you?", they asked. "Are you Elijah?" "No," he replied. "Are you the Prophet?" "No."
"Then who are you? Tell us, so we can give an answer to those who sent us. What do you have to say about yourself?"

Answer 9

The prophets said elijah must come before the Messiah - John was the fulfillment of the prophecy.

john denied it to the pharasee's because they really wanted to know who he really literally was - he was John, a servent a God.
not a dead prophet. not the messiah.

2 different times, I understand your confusion

Answer 10

in the jewish faith there is a concept of reincarnation, gilgul
and karma- hashgacha

however this is not karma or reincarnation in the sense of the western ideal where you get a new body or whatever
it is far more like the dzogchen teaching

for example, every cell in your eye ball is reincarnated in 24 hours
so really its not the same eyeball you had yesterday

or again, who you believe yourself to be changes

if you change your name from stephanie to sophia

once you were stephanie, but if someone asked you who you were
you would say im not stephanie, im sophia