How many of you so worried about the rights of Illegal Mexicans, in America, know Mexico's Immigration laws

Question

So some folks (illegals mostly) are crying about us cracking down on Illegal immigration. Mexico isn't a place you want to be an Illegal in, America is a cake walk compared to how Illegals are treated there. It doesn't seam like anyone wants to discuss that little fact, when slamming us for our treatment of Illegals. You hear the illegals here scream and shout about a death or two at our boarder. They might want to check on the statistics of deaths of Illegals in Mexico, by Federal police there. Ask a latino from any other south AMerican country how he might be treated when he crossed into Mexico Illegally, or legally for that matter. Frankly you don't have any rights in Mexico even if you enter legally. I'm tired of undocumented mexicans here complaining about how badly they are treated by us and how is it we owe them anything.

Agree or disagree.

Answer 1

I've read up on Mexico's Immigration laws and think we should do exactly what they do.

Answer 2

I agree,Ive read about how harsh Mexico's immigration laws are.Not lax like ours are
http://www.cbn.com/cbnnews/world/060815a.aspx

excerts from the link

But in Mexico, when it comes to the treatment of its illegal aliens it's, ‘Do as I say, not as I do.’

Mexico has called U.S. immigration policy "harsh," and has called the proposed wall on the U.S. Mexico border "shameful." But some have called the Mexican immigration policy "hypocritical."

Enter Mexico illegally and you're treated as a felon. If you're caught by the Federal Police, you'll be fortunate if you're only deported immediately. The unfortunate are robbed, abused, raped, or even murdered by corrupt police officers.

Fernando Aguilar Neri coordinates Red Cross efforts to help illegal aliens in Mexico.

“When people approach us, they are usually fearful that we work with the government and are afraid of being reported,” said Neri. “…One of the seven principles of the Red Cross is complete neutrality and independence, so we can't cooperate with the Mexican government on the illegal alien issue.”

Neri says that most illegals moving through Mexico try to avoid the cities.

Answer 3

confident, mexico could be extra in contact approximately their very own unlawful aliens extremely of lecturing america of a approximately our rules being enforced. in ingredient of actuality that Mexican drug retailers are much extra deadly than al-Qaida. they have extra firepower and additional funds and are merely as prepared to kill civilians as are the homicidal jihadists. yet, we individuals be attentive to little with regard to the chaotic concern south of the border. the reason being that the drug cartels do not seem to threaten us straight away. yet, of direction, they do. unlawful narcotics from Mexico land up in almost each and every community interior america. The FBI estimates that approximately 70 p.c. of crimes from coast to coast are drug-fueled. he recent atrocity in the Mexican drug conflict became into the invention of seventy two bodies on a ranch a hundred miles south of Texas. The lifeless -- fifty 8 adult males and 14 women human beings -- have been migrants from South and needed united statesa.. The lone survivor of the bloodbath says that cartel gunmen shot the unarmed human beings with the aid of fact they resisted an extortion attempt. The reliably anti-American manhattan circumstances partly blamed the mass killings on america of a: "Mexico's drug cartels are nourished from outdoors, by making use of American funds, heavy weapons and habit; the northward pull of immigrants is fueled by making use of our call for for low-salary hard paintings." I had to verify that editorial thrice to have self assurance it. here we've the circumstances, which opposes putting the national guard on the border, the not undemanding anti-alien regulation in Arizona and maximum different measures that could desire to guard the border, complaining with regard to the unlawful gun and drug site visitors. are you able to suspect this? hey, if america could deliver 10000 national Guardspeople to help the border patrol, drugs and weapons does not have the potential to go the border so actual. Comprende? This united states has the potential to stop the smuggling of human beings and medicines around the southern border. we could desire to try this. yet, for political motives, we don't. meanwhile, the drug cartels kill at will and create terror on a scale not seen everywhere else on earth in the present day. o_O

Answer 4

I totally agree with you. The illegal immigrants that are the majority in Mexico come from Guatemala. They are totally mistreated & the only thing they are allowed is very little medical attention if sick (only because of disease control). They are not allowed to attend Mexican schools & they don't get any free benefits like Welfare & WIC!!! That's just a start!!! I want to see what Pro-Illegals have to say about that. Will they play the race card with their own corrupt country (Mexico) the flag they love & support???

Answer 5

Agree...

Mexican Double Standard
By James Fulford

Many are aware that Mexico has long used a double standard on the question of immigration. A glance at the web page of the U.S. Embassy in Mexico City, gives an unofficial translation of Mexican immigration laws. There seems to be no category for unemployed American dishwashers, factory workers, meatpackers, or welfare clients to emigrate to Mexico.

Mexico insists that every immigrant shall do his duty, in the form of actual useful skills, or have a pension from his native land.

While American law enforcement agents are barred from asking people of Mexican appearance if they are secretly Mexicans, Allen Wall reports that Mexican police boarded a bus in Mexico and headed straight for the only man on the bus who was visibly American and asked him to prove that he was a legal resident.

The Mexican police, traditionally corrupt and brutal towards their own citizenry, are even more corrupt and brutal towards illegal immigrants, mostly from Central America. (The State Department wrote a blistering report in 2001 on human rights in Mexico.)

Mexico’s one-way attitude is best illustrated by the Mexican national anthem, Mexicanos al Grito de Guerra.

This national anthem is a clarion call to Mexican nationalists to defend their country to the last drop of blood. Nothing wrong with that. That’s what nationalism is all about.

But the anthem sounds very xenophobic, in that it says

But if some strange enemy should dare
to profane your ground with his step,
think, oh beloved country,
that heaven has given you a soldier in every son.

Even immigration skeptics don’t usually think of illegals as "profaning the ground with their step" ("profanar con su planta tu suelo"). Could these people be bigots, do you think?

I wonder what the patriotic Mexican author of that song, written in 1853 with Napoleon III in mind, would have thought if he’d awakened one morning, and found eight million Anglo-Saxon immigrants had entered his country illegally, or if there were a Mexican Broadcasting Corporation report that started “Mexico , inexorably, is becoming an Anglo-Saxon nation…”

He’d be furious.

But isn’t that what’s happening in the United States?

ABC News on wrote March 12th, 2002 that:

The United States, inexorably, is becoming an Hispanic nation, and today offers more hard evidence of the ongoing battle between the nation's two major parties for this increasingly crucial voting bloc (actually, voting blocs, though the parties and the political media tend to lump them all together).

Texas is Bush Country, But Is It Still Republican Country?

I’m not suggesting, in Enoch Powell fashion, that “like the Mexican” Americans should adopt the attitude of:

¡Guerra, guerra sin tregua al que intente
de la patria manchar los blasones!
¡Guerra, guerra! Los patrios pendones
en las olas de sangre empapad.

English translation;

War, war without truce to any who dare
to tarnish the country's coat-of-arms!
War, war! Take the national pennants
and soak them in waves of blood.

In fact I’m opposed to such an idea. Powell didn’t want bloodshed either, he was just predicting it.

But that’s the Mexican attitude, and when we hear that a Mexican Archbishop wants the US to adopt “humane” immigration laws, or that the President of Mexico wants Washington to change its immigration laws, perhaps Americans should say to them that “Charity begins at home”, or "Look in the mirror..."

It is pathetically poor that ones own country does not think of its own people's welfare and employment - AHEAD of the peope who are in power - own interests.

Don't believe me?

Just sneak into Mexico and see what happens to you!

Then tell me how unfair our policy is...

Answer 6

I agree with you 100%

They cry and whine here because we let them get away with it.

If anyone witnessed how criminals are treated in Mexico or any other Central American country, they would know how easy illegals have it here.

I have a friend from Guatemala who told me that the way Law Enforcement dealt with the homeless & vagrants there was to put them in a helicopter and drop them into a volcano! Can you imagine what the uproar would be if that happened here?

Answer 7

Mexico should try to protect itself from a hypocritical image, to be taken serious!.

Answer 8

Richard is right, we should handle illegals exactly the same way as Mexico handles their illegals.

Did you see how Eisenhower handled illegals?

http://www.csmonitor.com/2006/0706/p09s0...

Answer 9

the mexican goverment encourages its people to sneak in to the united states they its a corupt goverment. they cant support there people so they send them off here for them to overcrowd our society and programs.

Answer 10

AGREE......

BUT.

I'M NOT EVEN CONCERNED ABOUT MEXICO.
WHEN DID WE GO TO WAR?

I AM MORE CONCERNED ABOUT THE SHAFT BUSH IS GIVING AMERICAN CITIZENS...