Who thinks that depression should be classed as an illness on it's?

Question

own and not classed as a mental health problem? I am concerned that that word Mental has connitations and that it is unfair to a person who suffers from depression. Am I wrong in my thinking and how do you see it? Or is it something you have never given a great deal of thought about.

Just to remind you that mental health problems effects 1 in 4 of us during our lives and can strike at any time. And would you like to be classed as mental if you suffered or you knew someone who suffered from depression.

Amy Allen you assume too much!

Answer 1

I don't think you are either right or wrong, its just your opinion. I personally would not want to be classed as mental if I had depression. But there are some benefits to it being classed as a mental illness. For example, if a person became so badly depressed they might want to harm themselves in some way, sectioning that person under The Mental Health Act, would be good for their protection wouldn't it?

I think there is a really bad stigma against those with mental illnesses. What people need to remember is that it is an illness, and therefore cannot be helped in any way. Those who are scared of or make fun of those with mental illnesses simply do not understand and its the unknown which makes them scared of it. I think the general public should be made more aware of it.

A mental illness is so described because it's all to do with the brain. Depression is also to do with the brain. Most people experience depression at some point in their lives, for some it may be temporary and for others a long term thing. I think it is right that depression should be classed as a mental illness BUT I just think it is people's misunderstanding of what mental illness is which gives it it's bad reputation.

Answer 2

I am currently being treated for post-natal depression which i know is a bit different to "normal" depression but in the same ball park. when my health visiter said it is a mental illness i just sat there and thought "great... im a nut then" it doesnt do much for your confidence but then technically it is a mental health problem. To be honest i dont know what it should be called at the end of the day when you are diagnosed you feel relief that there is actually a problem and you arent cracking up but then you realise that you arent mentally correct so either way people are going to feel a little out of sorts about it for a while.
I know i balled my eyes out when i was told!

Answer 3

I truthfully have had the different issue. consistent minor infections, physique aches, swelling joints. After over a 300 and sixty 5 days of invasive and non invasive testing they ultimately clinically determined me with Hashimoto's and Lupus. right this is the kicker. Many medical doctors that I observed (9 finished) only categorized me as depressed. all of them gave me a similar rationalization as quickly as I mentioned I truthfully have a brilliant existence aside from being ill each and all of the time, how is somebody who's chuffed depressed. "melancholy comes from the interior and has not something to do with feeling unhappy". Like that one? i think you're able to desire to locate an immunologist or a homeopathic wellbeing practitioner who will inspect your finished image and would ultimately verify why you're ill and in discomfort and as quickly as you start to experience better your melancholy will ease up. solid success and verify out to be your guy or woman wellbeing care recommend.

Answer 4

I agree. It should be classified as a disease . Some people understand that it is a disease and some won't ever get it. My family has a history of this disease and I'm glad to see some people are catching on. Others though won't ever understand. I was raised by a bi-polar (sometimes borderline schizophrenic) mother. I fear someday it will effect me or my children. Like you say - it could strike at any time. I've had bouts with depression but through help of counseling and medication, I've bounced back.

Answer 5

depression is a mental illness, so i don't understand the question really.

Just like we have physical, organ, desease illnesses.

You wouldn't say someone was "mental", just as you wouldn't say someone was "physical" or "organ". Just because people cannot use the English language correctly doesn't mean we should re-classify an illness.

Stigma will always be attached to words. If someone is truely ill, a stigma will be of little importance to them....all i care about is that you help me get better.

Answer 6

I have depression and I have been in treatment for 3 years now. Having a mental problem release me, I dont care about others opinion. I agree that depression is a desease like diabetes, U need take your meds every day.

Answer 7

I agree with you !!! I suffer from psychotic depression (depression along with hallucinations - I usually hear a voice!). If you tell someone you suffer from depression, they are far more accepting of it, but you say you have mental health problems, they more often than not shy away.

Answer 8

Depression is more of a mental problem than a physical problem. If it is classified as an illness, I am concerned that too many people would fake it, take off from work and get paid sick leave just for goofing off. That is a serious injustice to those who are truly depressed.

Answer 9

I agree with you, but depression should be classified as mental health problem because it does have to do with your brain.
Most people need medications to balance the chemicals that have been imbalanced. I'm not trying to disagree, but that's my opinion, but I also think you're right.

Answer 10

what we need to do is to reduce the stigma of mental illness.You know of course that phobias, drinking problem and anxiety are all classified as mental illness. I think of we start doing what you suggest it will only increase the stigma of other illnesses.

The misconception of mental illness is fuelled by the media for example (escaped schizophrenic stabs a passenger). I think that the government,media and the public need to do more about reducing this stigma.