Where is the logic in thinking that "after" death is unlike "before" life?

Question

I personally have no recollections of "life" before I was born... In fact, I have few recollections that extend into early infancy. I assume that the bulk of you have similarly absent recollections. (I suspect that there may be a few freaks who believe otherwise.)

How then is it logical to believe that ones after death will be any different than ones before birth?

(Please answer without making useless scripture quotations that lend little help to advancing the logical response. Try using just you brain in answering this question... okay?)

I have considered that a human brain develops during life.... and yet I am unable to find that this fact could have any effect on "being" after death... please give your thoughts.

Answer 1

In answer to the question, none whatsoever.

It's most evident that all those "stories" about the people queuing up to answer God after death, are pure fiction, to use the most civil term.

Frankly, I'd like to see even one of those "Prophets" being able to prove he'd been there and really spoken with God.

Please do let me know how can anybody say that a "Religion" that was, at most, 6,000 years old, has all the Answers?

There are , no doubt, many good things to learn from "Religion" but to take everything as the Truth is ridiculous.

I'll take a bet that all these sanctimonious people are going to be in for one big shock when the event actually occurs.

Answer 2

I don't remember my life before six and vaguely at seven, yet I am one of those freaks. Would like to give my side, but really don't know where to start. Let me just assume you know what is karma( not necessary you believe). Before physical manifestation, the memory of your previous lives which houses your personality/character would be served as your template for your spirit( the same spirit with all of us) for your next materialization. That memory is still with you but your new brain has nothing to do with your old memory therefore it can not be recalled except under hypnosis. However, your current environment, relative, friends, enemies are those your reality you have created before birth, thus gaining new insight and experience as you journey your entire physical existence. Whatever you did in previous lives would come around for you to experience your own doing(good or bad) and learn.

Of course it is pretty much easier to think that nothing change before and after birth as it is logical. So you are right. I am freak.

Answer 3

My greatest occasion of that's specifically Metallica's Black Album. That became into certainly the 1st metallic album I ever heard, offered for myself, etc etc etc etc (i became into eleven). Now, i will't even pay attention to it in any respect with the aid of fact i've got come to sign in it as a severely watered down version of what they have been doing on AJFA. Which i could actual nevertheless pay attention to (although I on no account somewhat understood To stay is to Die... in the event that they're gonna honor Cliff, could not they have accomplished it with a extra valuable song?) yet another band I do prefer to point here, although for many motives I in the present day-up renowned that it is not honest, is Anthrax. I used to somewhat get into the huge 4 concern, yet by some potential over the years my hobby for listening to Anthrax merely diminished. what's strange is that my appreciation of their track hasn't. each and every time I do finally end up listening to Anthrax recently, i'm continually noticing how sturdy they even have been. what's distinctive is that now, it feels extra like being shocked by making use of it, extremely of merely be attentive to-the way it as a actuality like I used to. uncertain what the hell's going on there. yet endurance of Time continues to be a undesirable-@ss thrash/groove mid-pace masterpiece.

Answer 4

Religious questions are not subject to logic since no facts relevant to the matter can be empirically determined. In point of fact you are the one asserting that such a difference exists, it therefor falls to you to prove it. If you can't then your question becomes pointless, it's not up to someone else to argue your case for you.

Answer 5

It is impossible to correctly answer a spiritual question without quotes from the Holy Bible, which is the divinitive and final authority on spiritual matters, all else is merely uninformed, uneducated, finite, small thinking, personal opinion.

Answer 6

Before birth you do not exist, since it requires the coming together of man and woman (well, at least the man).

After death you have already existed.

Answer 7

This is our first existence . Upon awakening in the next part of our career , should we so choose , the only difference will be our KNOWLEDGE that survival is a reality.

Answer 8

It's the same "logic" that someone uses when they say that nothing existed before they were born.

Answer 9

I can't give any logic to that thought process, I have to agree with your thoughts on this

Answer 10

after death is very similar to before life silly. you have no experience or memories of either. because you're essentially dead