When a pregnant woman suffers a miscarriage, is God or is natural selection responsible for it?

Answer 1

duh its god.....

no such thing as natural selection.....

Edit!
Obviously my sarcastic undertones are going unnoticed! Hoehum

Answer 2

According to the bible, " through one man sin entered into the world, and death through sin, thus death spread to all men because they had all sinned." Romans 5:12. That one man was Adam, who joined the rebellion in Eden, and thus passed on imperfection to his descendants. God is most definitely not responsible for this. 1 John 5:19 clearly indicates who is. Is it natural selection? I don't think that would best describe it, but it is close. The bible says at Ecclesiastes 9:11 "time and unforeseen occurrence befall us all." That basically means that we age, and stuff happens. But there will be a time when no one will say " I am sick." Is it natural, the way things are now? I would have to say no, however, temporarily, that is the way it is. Keep in mind though, that there will be "..a resurrection of both the righteous and the unrighteous." Acts 24:15. That means that God plans on correcting everything wrong with this current system, in his due time. But he did have to allow time to go by to answer the challenge made in the garden of Eden, as to whether man could rule himself or not. I think man has proven beyond a shadow of a doubt whether he can or not. Wouldn't you agree?

Answer 3

I had two miscarriages. It is tough. It is amazing how perfect the human body is. It is amazing how everything is so detailed and finely constructed. I believe that their was a reason that the child did not continue to grow. I had learned through my experiences that my hormones where a problem. When I took Progesterone, It helped me able to carry children. The docor explained to me that if the baby had a problem, it would not make the baby continue to develop if the baby wouln't otherwise.

It goes to show how precious life is. God did not make my children, die. But God does allow certain things to take place. I do believe that I grew through my experiences and helped others since.

Answer 4

It is neither of those things. A miscarriage is just a biological occurance--nothing more nothing less. They happen for lots of different reasons (some are genetic so yes, natural selection can play a role).

Answer 5

If it's God or if it's nature....I can't say for sure.
I can only suppose that to blame God, would be an unreasonable response.
To believe that God works in mysterious ways and deny nature would also be an unreasonable response.

To assume that we don't know everything, makes the most sense to me.

Answer 6

Well it is mostly the women's body getting rid of a deformed or screwed up fetus. So neither god nor natural selection.

Answer 7

They say that 20% of all pregnancies end in miscarriage. For those who believe in God, it is comforting to believe that everything happens for a reason. Funny you should ask right now because my brother in law just lost his 2nd baby to miscarriage. He's in the service and his wife cheated on him while he was in Iraq, and he's about to go back there. I often wonder if it was God or fate or whatever intervening in their lives as though they are not meant to have another child together.

Answer 8

God is not responsible the Girl herself is responsible. She has done something in her previous birth that causes he to suffer a miscarriage

Answer 9

All was perfect until man sinned. Adam. He wanted the knowledge, he turned his back on God. From that point on, all of his descendants were cursed. It is not God's fault, it is man's through Adam. He turned his back, and none of us are any better.
http://planttel.net/~meharris1/mikescorner.html

Answer 10

I thought Nascar was natural selection.

Answer 11

Depends on your personal belief. If you believe in evolution, you'll say the baby had a problem that made it unviable and the mother's body naturally chose to reject the fetus. If you believe in intelligent design, you'll say that God did it for his own unknown reasons.