If a God existed, who made Judaism,Christianty,Islam, in this violent sequence, how would you feel about him?

Question

Naturally, the Jews, dont believe Yahweh created Christianty/Islam nor do the Christians believe he created Islam.

So this is an Islamic belief, the belief that a God, they call "allah" created Judaism, then Christianty, then finally settled on Islam.

Suppose this is true, how would you feel about such a God? I mean, he calls a people "the chosen people" or lets them believe that, then changes the whole ball game by sending Jesus to create the worlds largest religion.

Ok, Christians say hes the fullfillment of Jewish prophecy...Jewish doctrine I guess left itself open to that one...but imagine now the stretch Islam has reached.

So, this God knew that his actions would create these religions and they would fight among each other.

Seems illogical to me, I mean, if God is perfect, doesnt he get it right the first time?

Muslims respond by saying "Jews and Christiants corrupted Gods word". Ahh, so God started over and made the perfect being..."the Muslim"...LOL!!!

Answer 1

Ill-effective way to work.
If this "God" person exists, I'd ask that mean spaghetti monster to send me to Hell.

As I find more happiness in hell than In heaven. I find a guilty concious in heaven knowing that billions upon billions of people that i walked the earth with would be burning in hell. At least in H ell i would be thinking about my own self destruction(If I were in Hell) and not the destruction of other souls(if I were in Heaven).

If "God" wanted you to be in Heaven or Hell essentially he would have "Created" you there, and not here on Earth. It really seems like an illogical and illeffective way to work.

Answer 2

perfection don’t come from no where and people will not take perfect thing unless they masseur and see the diffrence, i belive there were true jews who believed in one god the creator, and god promised them for that heavens and lands on earth and in the next life but there were a new generation of Jew who disobey god which they were warned not to, god then send messenger and prophets but they where all killed and tortured, finally Jesus came to correct Judaism and to clarify the consumption amongst the Jew, He did not say am GOD or called for a new religion but for the same religion of worshiping the creator the all mighty. Jesus was chased for that and many people hated that a man with out a father can call for such a massage, the roman were angry and they tried to kill him but yet god decided to save him and take him to the havens where he is now, another man with a picture of Jesus was crossed and there is the meaning of Christianity come from the cross.

Islam came to be that last masses from god the perfect religion and i wouldn’t say (lol) on it coz it's a fact that Islam have the same values of the other 2 religions and more, despised the things Muslims are doing which i don’t think god is happy about.

this is wat i think about them 3 religions, they are from the same god but each one think is the best and there is only one chosen in god's eyes.

Answer 3

Ok when Judaism started it was the 'right' religion. So you could say they were muslims anyway. Those people corrupted the religion, and now judaism is not the same thing anymore as things have changed, the same goes for christianity. So Allah didn't create these religions. They were all the same thing at one point, but some just got altered and PEOPLE made new religions out of them...if that makes sense. ie, the judaism and christianity we have today, you could say, are the altered, corrupted Islam. Something like that.

And...replying to something someone said earlier. God didn't get it wrong the first time, people just screwed it up.

Answer 4

God did everything right in giving the law to Jews and sending Jesus to give us the truth, but arabs couldnt stop there.

God did everything right. It is only we as humans that have responded poorly, being divided, and not believing in Jesus.

Answer 5

Seems illogical to me, I mean, if God is perfect, doesnt he get it right the first time?

that sentence of yours shows the extent of your ignorance to me..

but I cant blame you for not knowing...only for not learning.

God is perfect yes.

Humans have free will.

God knows His creation just like a mother who knows what color his child would like his socks to be.

But God does not force you to do things.

You do them yourself.

And thus, God had warned people, in every age. Judaism wasnt the first religion. And it wasnt the last. but were nearing the end of civilization as we know it.

So the message was completed and locked from corruption and promised to be non corrupt for ages to come by God.

He had planned all this. And all we have to do..is stop asking stupid questions, but believe in The One God: that is not begotten and does not beget.

Peace

Answer 6

Do not be judgemental against God cause these scholars started the names of christianty.
god is not responsible for nothing that man has done apart from the lord.

Answer 7

Religion a result of too much intelligence of humanity, different interpretation, everybody claims they are the truth and righteous. Whoever is the right one I know Jesus is the only way.

Answer 8

First the Jews do see Jesus but only as a prophet,,Christains see Him as the one who died on the cross,,Muslim came from a different tribe and went to Muhammad..Yahweh is the same Jesus they just dont see it...He came once but they think He has never came..

Answer 9

jews may not agree that mohammed was a prophet or that the koran is from g-d, but we can definitely see why g-d created islam for the gentiles. g-d wants as many people to embrace him as possible, and islam has helped a billion people to do so.

Answer 10

I personally believe that all three religions have been misinterpretated, especially Christianity and Islam. This is because of people though, not God. Someone can give you good advice all day long, but ultimately it is up to you what you do with it.