English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

I'm thinking about buying something new...any input about either of these, or something else?
I'd want to stay in the 40 cal range...but what brand has the most reliability and ease of use...home defence.
budget is around 500 at the moment.

2006-11-08 22:37:34 · 9 answers · asked by Diadem 4 in Politics & Government Law Enforcement & Police

Thanks Jon, good advice.

2006-11-08 22:52:51 · update #1

This afternoon i went and shot a few different glocks(17,17c,23) good stuff, but i liked the ruger p345 the most.
thanks all- gonna add the ruger to my meager collection.

2006-11-09 08:23:48 · update #2

9 answers

Find a range that rents .... always try before you buy ...Glocks are preferred by law enforcement because of the integrated trigger and grip safety ... in short there isn't really a safety if you grip the gun with your finger on the trigger ....because of this there have been alot of accidental shootings .... Why do you want the weapon.....do you have a need to draw and fire quickly (like a cop on a traffic stop) then yes the Glock .... There were shooting incidents where law enforcement forgot to take the safety off ... that's why the Glock is so popular ..there is not lever or button to press the fire ..just grip & go....

I have the seperate safety ... I hate the accidental discharge potential of a weapon I carry on my person..... I prefer to think before I fire.

But to each his own......

You do test drive a car before your buy onw right ..... when you invest the money in something for self defence you should know how it works and handles before you take it home!

Happy Huntin'

2006-11-09 03:41:51 · answer #1 · answered by John 7 · 1 0

Glocks while outstanding guns and state of the art when they came out, are now a bit dated and other guns are better. Look at a Springfield Armory XD 45 Compact. The advantages over a Glock are: 1. Magazine has 10 rounds vs 9 for the Glock. Both magazines are legal in California. 2. 45 ACP has more power than a 40 cal S+W. 3. Second magazine that comes with the SA has 13 rounds with an extension on the magazine so it now is the same size as the service model. May be an issue in California but in the other states if you have to go to the second magazine, the extra length of the grip and more rounds is considered a plus. 4. Glock trigger safety does not have the same contour as the trigger. After a long day at the range, you will end up with a groove in your finger from the safety. The SA trigger safety has the same curve as the trigger so your finger does not get sore. 5. Glock has ONLY that trigger safety. Catch it on something as you put the gun in your holster and it CAN go off The SA has a grip safety which eliminates that risk. 6. The Glock uses a fat walled plastic magazine around a thin metal liner, so the grips are big. The SA uses a flat steel walled magazine so you can get more rounds in for the same size grip. If you do not think this is a problem, for Glock to get about the same power and rounds into their gun as the SA can, the Glock company had to invent their own cartridge, the 45 GAP. Give a XD a try before you go get a Glock. I think you will find it a better gun.

2016-05-21 23:57:31 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

The arguement can be made that any 1911 is the most popular handgun right now because most gun makers are making a version of the old slabside.

I carry a .45 Springfield 1911 A-1 GI it ran me around $500 no FTE,FTF

There are companies that make a 10 MM in the 1911 frame, which is about the size of .40 S&W but is more powerful

I also carry a Springfield XD 9 that is a fun weapon. I know that they have the XD in a .40

2006-11-08 22:58:41 · answer #3 · answered by .45 Peacemaker 7 · 1 0

Glocks are considered to be very good. Although I recently sold my Glock 22 for a Springfield XD 9 mm.
Personally it shoots better than the Glock. Taurus are brazilian made. Cheap knock off's of a Baretta. Personally I prefer the XD, since my shot group is far better. They also have them in 40 cal. and for around the same price as the Glock (if you are Law enforcement)

2006-11-09 03:07:54 · answer #4 · answered by spanishflyin_tx 3 · 1 0

I have both, but I prefer the Glock 21 or 21C (45acp), both are truly a pleasant shooting firearm. The only problem I have with the 27 is that the lower receiver isn't as beefy and I feel more recoil with it compared to the 21, you will of coarse feel even less with any of the compensated models, which I personally like. If at all possible find a indoor shooting range that rents guns to give them a try, there is nothing worse that having a fire arm that you are not happy with. Stay safe and have fun.

2006-11-08 22:47:17 · answer #5 · answered by Jon 2 · 2 0

I am a federal agent and use my handgun about twice a month,when I first started I was told that glocks are mandatory.I carried a 45 caliber and was really dissatisfied with its performance.The only great feature is the safety position on the gun!I presently carry and prefer a Smith and Wesson 3.75, 45 caliber,while the safety is not as good as the glock the stopping power is greatly appreciated.My wife uses a 9mm for home protection and shoots it very accurately.The stopping power is not to my caliber but it is perfect for her.

2006-11-09 04:30:02 · answer #6 · answered by riordanjsca 2 · 1 0

I would not recommend the baby Glock in any caliber. Granted it is small and easy to conceal, but it is hard to control. I own a full size Glock Model 22, in the .40 S&W caliber. It is one super gun, and This is what I would recommend. The next smaller size is the Model 23, which is an inch shorter barrelwise, and a quarter inch shorter in the butt. Choose what you want wisely, because once you leave the store, the gun is yours, no exchanges.

2006-11-08 23:10:16 · answer #7 · answered by WC 7 · 1 0

The Sig and the Glock are the two most commom US weapons used by police. Really a toss up which one is used most.

I am a personal Glock fan, but don't like the baby glock

2006-11-09 03:32:25 · answer #8 · answered by Anonymous · 1 0

Might want to take a look a Sig Saur also. I believe they are the best all around shooting semi I've ever shot

2006-11-08 23:49:47 · answer #9 · answered by mark g 6 · 1 0

fedest.com, questions and answers