would you try this salad recipe?

Question

lettuce
tomatoes quartered
apples peeled & chopped up (red delicious)
white sugar or brown
and mayo
my husband loves it.

Answer 1

is that like a waldof salad?..sounds like it..many people put walnuts over it.

It's a tasty salad.

Answer 2

I may have to try this, I KNOW that mayo/sugar dressing is great with lettuce and tomatoes, so throwing in the apples might be a good twist....I think I'll try it!

Answer 3

I would try it....
Then maybe I will tweak it to suit me and change the sugar for honey and added to the mayo. Maybe a little squirt of lemon and some kind of nuts are starting to sound really good. A kicked up Waldorf Salad version.
*** but I will try it just as you descirbe it first then maybe do my own little twists.

Answer 4

Sounds close to my mom's waldorf salad. Except she used Cool Whip, grapes instead of tomatoes, and walnuts. I've heard mayo can be used in place of Cool Whip.

Answer 5

I would prefer more than just tomatoes and apples.

What the heck is the sugar for?

Answer 6

I suppose I could give it a try. Not my first choice, though. Waldorf salads usually have a bit of celery and nuts, though, too. Sometimes with grapes added.

Answer 7

Something about tomatoes and sugar just gives me the heebie jeebies.

Answer 8

i hates mayo and apples in salads especially together

Answer 9

I would love to it sounds delisous
Mabe ill try it tonight

Answer 10

I don't like mayo but yes with oil& vineagar.