compare and contrast Judaism, Christianity, and Islam's view of humans and human nature?

Answer 1

well judaism and islam both see man as naturally good.

haha...but just take a look at the freakin world.

christianity is accurate when it proclaims man is prone to sinful nature.

btw..christianity is the ONLY religion that says this. every other religion in the world portrays humans as "good"

Answer 2

Ancient Judaism and Christianity share the same views on hman nature: that we ae created in the image of God but that this image is broken with the fall into sin. (The difference in belief is how this is corrected). Both also believe that man was given the possibility of making choices and thus affecting his fate.
From what I hear, Islam seems more fatalistic: man's decisions would account to nothing, because God (or Alla) decides everything ahead of time.
Judaism and christianity also teach predestinaiton and election, but these take into account man's decisions.

Answer 3

Christianity: Believes that man is born in a sinful state, is inherently sinful and incapable of not sinning or correcting a sin. Therefore, the only salvation is via the faith and grace that the sacrifice of God will expiate all sins past, present and future. In short, no personal responsibility because one is incapable of saving oneself anyway.

Islam: Man is subject and slave to God and the only thing that prevents the ultimate form of that relationship are evil external factors and forces, whether spiritual or physical. the road to salvation can only be trod by destroying all that which is not Islam. Bottom line: It's not my fault....victim mentality.

Judaism: man is ultimately responsible for his own salvation. Sin can be remediated through actions and seeking forgiveness. each person makes their own 'world to come'. Good works stand on their own as merits for a person. Bottom line: It's all on use....let's make the best of it.

Answer 4

at the start, my I propose which you lose the 'dominant' faith jargon? it incredibly is an over-simplification and it is likewise incorrect for many of the international's inhabitants. Judaism is in consistent communicate with ALL of its custom. you would know the Christianized version of our unique texts, with all of its wee edits that create 'prophecies' for Jesus to fulfill. We even have layers of commentaries on those unique texts, and commentaries on the commentaries, etc. Jewish custom is careful approximately the way it amends itself. Take animal sacrifice. besides being the wider cultural prepare of the time, it made various experience for nomadic shepherds. It did no longer artwork so nicely throughout the time of the Babylonian exile, while the 1st Temple replaced into destroyed and the persons have been unfolded. they had to return up with an option, which replaced into prayer, to fulfill those commandments. To an outsider, it would make extra experience to in basic terms do away with the verses commanding Temple sacrifice. To Jews, which would be dishonoring Torah. incredibly, we understand that the prayer amenities thoroughly fulfill the commandments.

Answer 5

I will speak of my religion only, I have no right to boast my knowledge of the othe religions:
Islam: we are born sinless. How can a baby have a sin? don't tell me that our father Adam (pbhu) passed on his sin to us? God is all mercifull, He will not punish U for another's sins. Now that you are all pure when U come to the world, it's up 2 U 2 stay pure or otherwise. U will face consequences of your actions on Judgement Day.
Peace.

Answer 6

the first thing that comes to mind, is that Judaism has no concept of Original Sin, that is, that we are born Innocent, and that while we have an imperfect nature, ... incomplete... and we make mistakes, and do the wrong thing, knowingly and unknowingly, its our choice.

its not that humans aren't "sinful" in nature, as such, but that this nature is something entirely subject to our own choices.

incomplete perception results in imperfect behavior.

Answer 7

Do I have to? YAAAAYYY!!!