How do I tell my fiance politely that I will nOT sign a pre-nuptual agreement?

Question

He wants to protect all that he will "inherit" from his family.

We are both 20 years old, and I find it absurd to sign pre-nups at our age when our only assets are our cars.

Any suggestions! please!

Answer 1

Why don't you just sign it?!?!?!??!
It sounds like you DO want an inheritance.

Answer 2

I find it ridiculous and ashamed for them when I see people live their whole life waiting and counting on that inheritance from mommy and daddy.
Are you sure you want to marry this guy? He sounds like a tool. I mean, you could take the upper hand and go see an attorney first, and tell the attorney you need to be "protected" when you inherit from your parents.
He is being absurd. If you really want to marry him, I would highly advise getting your own attorney to look over any pre-nups he throws at you, just so you know what you're getting if there is a divorce. And also consider having him make out a will, it would decide what you would get if he were to die, make sure the house will be paid off and get the life insurance money squared away.
It sounds cut throat, but he was the one who brought it up.
Good luck.

Answer 3

This is not a flame.

But if your Yahoo name is Sex Bot, then he likely sees you exactly as you see yourself. He probably wants the pre-nup because he doesn't see the marriage lasting very long.

Let me guess, it's you that is pushing the marriage part.

Get some self-worth and be sure you are marrying someone for the right reasons. Even for the right reasons, there can be reasons for a pre-nup, since half of marriages end in divorce.

Answer 4

Being factual, concise and assertive are very polite ways of getting your point across. You shouldn't have to sugar coat anything you want to tell him. If you do, I think you should re-evaluate your situation with this man.

Why should he be concerned about sharing what didn't cost him a drop of blood, sweat or tears to make. The money he will inherit is found money. Would he not share a hundred dollars with you if he were to find it on the sidewalk?

Regardless of what assets he wants to protect from you, you should think about the implications this type of greed could have in the future. Do you really feel comfortable with a man this interested in material wealth? Does he love you enough to overlook his greed and twisted sense of love. commitment and relationship?

Think hard and deep before making any decisions.

I wish you the best!

Answer 5

Try this:

"My love, I am not comfortable signing a prenuptual agreement. If this means we don't get married, that's probably for the best, because the fact that we're both 20 years old and our only assets are our cars and you want a prenup suggests to me that you don't want a lifetime commitment. Since I do, I'll ask you to reconsider this idea. But I have considered it all I need to and the answer is absolutely no."

...or something like that.

Answer 6

Very comfortable problem. i think it incredibly relies upon on who needs the pre-nup, him or his mom and dad. the two way it should not be common. i think a sturdy question is, how long have you ever favourite on the subject of the funds that he stands to inherit? in case you have favourite approximately it for a protracted quantity of time, even previously the engagement, then i'm able to understand why he/they want one signed. in case you in basic terms in the near previous found out approximately it, then i do no longer think of it incredibly is a justified request. What you are able to desire to do it sit down and communicate with him approximately it. tell him which you know why every physique might decide to guard their destiny funds, yet you like him for him no longer his funds. If he nevertheless feels the want for a pre-nup, maximum pre-nups have a clause put in there that states some thing to the effect that his inheritance is his, yet all issues gained throughout marriage would be chop up in case of divorce. tell him if he's so damned traumatic approximately his funds, that the inheritance can circulate right into a separate account it incredibly is in basic terms in his call, and that your "mutual" funds would be in a joint account. If he can no longer settle for those words, then i do no longer know if he's rather well worth retaining onto, sorry to assert.

Answer 7

Inheiritances are not community property in any state in the country so the arguement of "protecting" it is bogus. On the other hand, if all you two have is cars for assets, why are you afraid to sign a prenup - have you even seen what it says?
I'd like to know the whole story. There are clearly other reasons for the prenup other than the inheiritance.
You are between a rock and a hard place...don't sign it and look like a gold-digger, sign it and look like a fool.
If I had a "legititmate" reason for a prenup and you refused to sign I'd drop you like a hot potato (can you spell "gold-digger"?)

Answer 8

Prenup will protect both you and your partner. I made my boyfriend sign a legal agreement like that before he was allowed to move into my house. I did this to protect me. He has nothing and I have a house and car. I didn't want him to be entitled to 1/2 of everything if he moved out in the future since we would be commonlaw.

He was probably a little insulted, but it was to protect me. The agreement pretty much was that what we brought into the relationship, we take when we leave, and 1/2 of the joint purchases.

Don't be insulted by a pre-nup, especially since more than 1/2 of marriages fail. Protect yourself!!

Answer 9

Contrary to how you feel, I think that pre-nups are good to have when there might be a lot of money to be had later on. Don't be so hard nosed about this, if you really love him.

Answer 10

tell him you aren't going to get married. pre nuptual agreement is mandatory. not signing one is tantamount to saying "when we break up I am going to rake you over the coals."

when you first started sleeping together I am sure you wore condoms. this is protection that may have been unneccessary in retrospect, however it was a wise choice at the time. so to with pre nuptual agreements.

Answer 11

Perhaps he is planning on coming in to some money. Perhaps he is being pressured by his parents who will leave him a great deal in their wills. Tell him in no uncertain terms how you feel. If neither is willing to meet the other in the middle then be prepared to move on with your life. You must decide if you want to be married or right. Sometimes it's worth the fight, sometimes it's not. Choose your battles dear. Best wishes.