This is for people who know Bojutsu. Should you have to keep your hands on the Bo at all times?

Question

In my association they want your hands on the Bo at all times, but me and a freind have made up our own Bo Kata for demos and tournaments that we take our hands off it while its spinning in the air. We have had instructors all the time telling us that this kata is good but not traditional and therefore may not impress to many traditional martial artists. What do you think about this? Should it be allowed?

Answer 1

Lots of people seem to like the flash and dash demonstrations, but as a traditional martial artist, I believe that if there is no purpose behind the movement, then the movement is wasted and only serves to provide your opponent with an opening. If you release both hands from your weapon then you have effectively give it to your opponent, or at least have allowed him to take it from you.

Sure, I like to see the fancy movements, in the same way I like to watch fireworks (they are pretty but are fleeting and without substance) but I would never be inspired to practice them since they have no meaning. If I were attacked by someone breaking into my house and had a broomstick to use as a weapon, I would never let go of it and certainly never throw it up in the air spinning.

So yes, your instructors are correct. If you want to impress the kiddies, go for the flash, but if you want to impress serious martial artists, then you have to put substance behind your kata. Movement should not be wasted (each move has a reason, such as you are either blocking, striking, sweeping, etc. not moving for the sake of moving) and each movement should have the ability to create multiple interpretations (could be explained as a block or strike, etc.) and should be crisp and focused.

Answer 2

That is just to flashy with the Bo spinning in the air. What really is the point of it. Thats something you would see the color guard of a marching band do not a Martial Artist. It might look good but you got to think does it really serve a purpose.

Answer 3

the whole point of a "demo" is to showcase your skills with the bow. If you are going for a flashy looking style then go for it.... but you will only cater to those who dont understand the traditional side of your art.