seamless or seamed vinyl siding?

Question

i have two estimates for siding my house. one is seamless, prefered because of the look, the other is seamed, contractor says this is better because it allows for expansion and contraction. i live in upstate ny, so we do have vast differances in tempuraters throughout the year. would like to hear from contractors or homeowners with experiance. thanks

Answer 1

Before, I even read your explanation, I voted for seamed siding. The siding will expand with the heat and the cold and the seams allow room for that. Vinyl siding tends to be brittle. When the temperature changes we can hear the siding making a snapping sound.

Answer 2

I have installed both types of vinyl. Either one will suit your needs. The seamless will allow for expansion also as long as it is installed correctly. Expansion and contraction rarely varies more than 1/4" unless there are extenuating circumstances. I know a few contractors that prefer the seamed vinyl siding, simply because it is easier to install, more readily available, and quicker. Make sure you get references of other jobs the installers have done with the various products. You might check to see if they are employees or subcontractors also. I've been both, so I don't have anything against either one. I've just found that you can trust a guy alot more when he is the one doing the work, signing the checks and standing behind the installation. Good luck.

Answer 3

i see alot of companies(high pressure sales) usinf "seamless vinyl). i use 20 foot length but nothing bigger. does'nt longer siding reduce rigidity? if it was such a good idea everyone would offer it. anyone know any other negatives on seamless?