Would it be better for my husband and his estranged 14-yr-old daughter to go to a psychologist, psychiatrist?

Question

Or a family counselor, etc.? I know there are differences between these professionals, and his daughter seemed worried that he said the word "psychiatrist". She said why not a counselor? Does anybody here have any insight? She has been aliented from, and poisoned against him by her mother. There is no other way than therapy for them to get their relationship back on track. We love her and want her to be a part of our family as well as her mother's.

Answer 1

Go to a family counselor or a psychologist. psychiatrists usually deal with prescribing meds for psychological problems and a counselor knows how to talk things out. make sure the counselor is a good match for both of them --they both need to trust the counselor and be comfortable telling them everything. if the first one doesnot work out don't be afraid to fire them and find someone else. good luck

Answer 2

A psychiatrist only prescribes meds very few do actual counseling. The difference between a family counselor and a Psychologist is schooling. The family counselor has a masters degree and a psychologist has a Ph.D. Either of those professionals could help in this situation a good clinician knows their limits and if it is too much for the family counselor to handle then he/she should refer you to the Psychologist. The hardest part is going to be the fact that you can't change her mother. Good Luck!

Answer 3

Psychiatrists seem to deal mostly with psychiatric problems that often need medication.

I would say a counselor of some kind, in part because that's what the daughter seems comfortable with and it may make her more likely to give the counseling an actual chance. Maybe the mother should be involved in some way with this, too, I don't know.

Answer 4

A Psychiatrist has the ability to prescribe medications, and diagnose disorders. A Psychologist can diagnose but not prescribe medicine, uses talk-therapy. And Counselors will serve as primarily talking counseling, and counselors can be a wealth of information for local services and programs to recommend

Answer 5

Actually, for this kind of interpersonal relationship problem, I've found that a good Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW), or Clinical Pastoral Counselor, may be the best person to see. They tend to focus on the broad picture of how people are getting along in the constellation of their relationships and know a lot about the structure of groups including family groups.

Answer 6

PhD are the best trained in therapy.
some msw's are good but if its a one chance thing to get her to go
research on local web sites any teenage runaway shelters or other programs and get a referral . and call for a chat first. and interview them.
last thing you need is an ivory tower type or overworked unskilled govt employee who doesn't know how to relate and make the kid feel comfortable and safe.
let the child help decide the choices and if the person feels right give her some power and she'll feell a lot better and a lot more liek coooperating.

good luck.!!!!!!!

a psychiatrist best trianed in medical conditions and medications.

Answer 7

Counseling would be the most practical. A Psychiatrist can prescribe medicine. And a counselor can not. Look in your phone book, under mental health. Or call your County Health Department - I bet they can refer you to the help that they need to get back to working on their relationship/

Answer 8

If your husband does not have a bond with the child , then the child thinks of him as a stranger.
A counselor will do him or her no good whatsoever.
Dont scare the child, she is at a vulnerable age.
It is best to get on good terms with the mother of the child and do for the child instead of traumatizin the child with shrinks.
The child needs love, not counselor.
Buy the child teen magazines, and music cds and take the child to movies, skating, etc.
Bringin a couselor or psych in the situation usually makes things worser.
Let this stay in the family and help each other instead of putting each other down. THINK POSITIVE>

Answer 9

regrettably counseling, treatment, and so on, do not artwork, young children in basic terms understand one component: Step a million) Take all of her toys away. Step 2) Take her television priveledges away. Step 3) If she throws a in good structure over the first step or 2, tell her that if she ever needs to have any of her toys decrease back or watch television back, she is going to commence exhibiting you and her instructors some understand. I say you, because I heavily doubt that if she is appearing up in college that she is treating you any in yet differently, and with the uncommon exception, father and mom in a lot of situations shoulder lots of the blame for a way their toddlers act. She needs to charm to close that her habit is unacceptable, and except she has an ideas-set replace, that her toys will commence being thrown away one by technique of one, and he or she will be able to not be allowed to computer screen television, play outdoors, or see any of her acquaintances. Assign her some chores, and make certain she does them. tell her that she will earn decrease back her toys and different priveledges by technique of doing those chores, and by technique of exhibiting progression in college. it could be puzzling, yet you may want to be strict - toddlers can tell once you're weak willed, and they'll take finished income of it.

Answer 10

mostly these days,
psychiatrists don't spend much time talking with you, they just prescribe pills (which is cool, if that's what you need).

But sounds to me like your situation would call for more counseling (than prescription medications), so a psychologist or counselor would be your best bet.