If we had a gradeless education system, would it work?

Answer 1

No

Answer 2

I think it depends on which level you're talking about. In higher education there are already many gradeless schools/programs (like Harward MBA which is unfortunately due to change soon) and it works better because students put their attention to team work, really learning the material etc. instead of backstabbing and competition. In K-12 and for normal kids grade system probably works better.

Answer 3

I don't believe a gradeless education system would work, at least in elementary school. My son's grades in 5th grade improved when he began to experience academic competition with his friend. I just had a parent teacher conference. My son had all A's except with respect to his reading log where he had a low "C" average. He did not know the reading log was graded. I'm sure this week's grade will be better!

Answer 4

Absolutely not. At least in a middle school setting. The 8th graders I teach are not intrinsically motivated enough to care about learning if they're not getting something back for their effort. Grading is like their "payday". How many of us would actually get up, go to work, and put forth our best effort everyday if at the end of the week all we got was a portfolio of our work or a pat on the back? It's sad, but it's reality.

Answer 5

Without some form of measurement how would you know if it worked or not. Not saying grades are the only way, but you need some system.

Answer 6

Not unless there is some type of other motivation to keep people interested in learning. If there is nothing to work for, people would tend to not pay attention to subjects that don't hold their interests.

Answer 7

Sure. Learning is what's important. Have portfolios of work instead of grades.

Answer 8

Ofcourse. As long as you understand what you're learning, that's all that matters.