Vick for McAllister?

Question

I've been offered Mike Vick for Duece McAllister. My team currently look like this:
QB: Farve & Bledsoe
RB: Larry Johnson & Tatum Bell & Duece McAllister
WR: Steve Smith & Torry Holt
TE: Alge Crumpler & Kellen Winslow
K: Vinatari & Gould
DST: Bears

I think I should take the trade because the QB Dallas situation has me a bit uneasy but RB go down fast and I think McAllister would make a good backup if one of my starters gets hurt later.

What should I do?

Answer 1

he's only offering you vick now because of his 4TD game last week. he's trying to sell while vick's value is high. there's no way i would take vick and give up mcallister. you got a really good team so don't screw it up. there should be plenty of solid QB options that you can pick up in free agency.

Answer 2

First off, scour the free agents list for any type of qb that is out there. Maybe a Kitna or a Alex Smith or somebody that can be a fascilitator on your team. Mike Vick, though he has had a couple of good games, just isn't a great fantasy choice. His stock is very high right now because of those couple of good games so Vick owners are trying their best to get whatever they can in deals involving him. If I were you, I would not overpay for Vick because he will eventually show his true, inconsistent colors. I wouldn't trade away deuce for him. You would definitely be overpaying. I would drop a kicker and find yourself a backup wr.

Answer 3

Your in determined want of a #a million RB. Edgerin James isn't putting up #a million option numbers. And its because of Arizonas O Line. i became a sufferer of the Portis 2. he's out for a month and in all likelihood theyll save him out the season. So dont attempt this commerce. Vick has been doing nicely till previous week the position hes been slideing. yet definetly commence brees. yet seem for a Ronnie Brown or Rudi or Westbrook or possibly a Frank Gore attempt puzzling to get Willie Parker he has been on fireplace and your RB's will go decrease back to being elite

Answer 4

I'd pull the trade and hope for the best. Bledsoe is worthless. You might consider looking on the waiver wire first or try to get Romo. Farve is your obvious starting QB. Depth at RB is a nice to have.

Answer 5

I would take it simply for the QB situation unless you can pick up a decent option. Same is said for RB where you can pick up a rb that is playing a weak run defensive team.

Answer 6

Usually I'd say no, but your QB situation is terrible. You need any QB you can get. I would do the trade!