i know my sentences below are incorrect, please tell me them correctly. also what is difference between them?

Question

1-who did decide about what we need to have as of clothes?
2-who has decided about what we need to have as of clothes?

Answer 1

1 - who did decide about what we need to have as of clothes?

"Who did decide..." is an all right way to do past tense, even though it is awkward. It would be easier to say "Who decided..."

"About what we need to have" is also all right, even though awkward.

"as of clothes" is the wrong part. You have several options here: " ... in regards to clothing" would complete the sentence properly. Your easiest solution, though, would be to move the "clothes" part to earlier in the sentence:

"Who did decide about what clothes we need to have?"

the "what" can introduce the object of the following clause, in this case, clothes. "As of..." is never a good way to introduce an object or most other clauses. It should only be used in telling time. "As of yesterday, we were sad."

2-who has decided about what we need to have as of clothes?

Same basic problem here. "Who has decided about what we need to have" is fine. But not the "as of" part. So it should be "Who has decided about what clothes we need to have?"

However, in both sentences the "about" is redundant (it just implies that this was a standing question, which it doesn't seem to be.) "Who has decided about the war?" Makes sense. OR "Who has decided about the clothes?" But when you have a "what" there, it serves the same purpose of introducing the indirect clause (though it requires a verb). SO "Who has decided what war will be fought?" "Who has decided what clothes we need to have?"

OR, obviously, "Who did decide what clothes we need to have?"

The only remaining issue is the difference between "Who has decided" and "who did decide." I could be mistaken here, but I'm pretty sure that they are just different ways of constructing a past tense. You could also use "Who decided," as in, "Who decided what clothes we need to have?"

Answer 2

Look at your other question of the same content....
"Who decided what we need for clothing?"

Answer 3

the variations between here 2 sentences specializes interior the era of previous time. the 1st sentence, I truthfully have been to London, ability that the guy pointing out that sentence he or she became in London purely a quick time interior the previous. on the different hand, the guy announcing he or she were to London became there an prolonged volume of time interior the previous. sturdy luck.

Answer 4

"Who has decided what clothes we need to bring for the trip?"

or

"Who is going to decide which clothes to bring for the trip?"

this is the best that i could think of...

Answer 5

Okay, neither of these sentences make any sense.

Please tell us about yourself. Your age, your native language, what you are doing to learn English. Then maybe we can help or explain things.

Answer 6

Cheating for your paper is not a good idea. =o)

Answer 7

wow....i have no idea!
sorry.