Prove me wrong on these:
1) Jesus said He came to die on the cross and was risen to Heaven. mohamad said he believed in Jesus and His words.
Why then did mohamad said jesus didnt die but sent an imposter to die? Since when did Jesus said He will tell a lie and send someone 600 yrs later to tell the truth?
2) why did mohamad sleep with the wife of his slave?
3) why did mohamad marry a 6 yrs old and enjoyed revalations only on her bed? u mean, its acceptable that i make love to your 6 yrs old daughter or relatives now if im a prophet?
4) why did mohamad insist that being only a messenger of God, he couldnt perform any miracles nor give prophecies? he himself said so in the sura.
5) why did he, at the age of more than 50, look at a female baby and said he will marry her if hes alive when she grows up?
All these were from the sura or quran, read b4 u say im making things up.
http://bibleprobe.com/muhammad.htm
http://www.faithfreedom.org/Articles/quran_teaches.htm
2006-10-17 23:36:59 · 24 answers · asked by Anonymous in Society & Culture ➔ Religion & Spirituality
haha i can see lots of defender giving the thumbs down to my question without an answer, simply because they're so dumbfounded by the truth. great!
i've seen how people defend his sleeping with the children as acceptable, but now too many points are raised that they cant say anything but to admit the truth, and give this a thumbs down, then feel sore about the loser Mr. M.
2006-10-17 23:43:09 · update #1
babyyocca says that im basing my question on wrong books.
ARE U SAYING THE SURA AND QURAN ARE WRONG?
if u say that its wrong it means muslims are wrong. BUT seriously, either way they are wrong.
2006-10-17 23:46:49 · update #2
yh u are right. i left islam coz its just so ridiculous. But u have to remember that muslims have been follwing islam for generations and so it is difficult to say anything to muslims to make them understand. its like saying something bad abt ur fav footie team, u are gonna stick up 4 them when some critises them
2006-10-17 23:41:30 · answer #1 · answered by Anonymous · 4⤊ 10⤋
1) Jesus said He came to die on the cross and was risen to Heaven. mohamad said he believed in Jesus and His words.
we dont believe in that bec its not true and the bible was proved to be corrupted
2) why did mohamad sleep with the wife of his slave?
he (PBUH) married her after being divorced
3) why did mohamad marry a 6 yrs old and enjoyed revalations only on her bed? u mean, its acceptable that i make love to your 6 yrs old daughter or relatives now if im a prophet?
see full answer at my blog http://360.yahoo.com/ahmad.egypt
4) why did mohamad insist that being only a messenger of God, he couldnt perform any miracles nor give prophecies? he himself said so in the sura.
he didnt said he is the only messanger but the seal of the prophets,he gave many miracles read about it at http://islamway.com
5) why did he, at the age of more than 50, look at a female baby and said he will marry her if hes alive when she grows up?
where did you read it and what is your proof
2006-10-18 07:18:26 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 5⤊ 4⤋
"You talk about the bad parts. How about the good parts? Do you see any good part in Islam or all what you see is bad?"
"In every religion, there is something good, something bad and something very ugly. The good part is what is being preached, the inner peace and security that it promises. The bad part is the hidden agenda of their founders and how that religion is practiced. The ugly part is the terrible outcome and the disastrous toll that it takes from its followers and not followers. All the religions share the same characteristics. Except Buddhism that is not a religion but an agnostic philosophy of enlightenment. Buddhism makes no mention of God or any deity and Buddha never made any claim of receiving a revelation.
I should also mention that all religions have evolved and they are now positive forces of change. Islam is the only religion that has not changed and cannot change."
This quote is by Ali Sina an ex-muslim from Iran.
2006-10-18 07:23:27 · answer #3 · answered by NoLabel 11 4 · 2⤊ 3⤋
I'll answer your questions in the same manner, with points. But the only difference between me and you is reason, and respect, which is something you must learn first.
1) Mohammed (PBUH) did believe in Jesus and Moses. And Mohammed (PBUH) never said Jesus Sent an Imposter to replace him. He said GOD sent someone who looks like him to replace him, and he had taken Jesus to heaven. Which means that Islam has high regards for Jesus, and that in our point of view he is still alive in heaven. Second, Jesus didn't say He'll tell a lie and that Mohammed (PBUH) will come and tell the truth. He said that a man named Ahmed will come in about xxx years and deliver a new message, and he ordered his people to follow him. (Review history before you post questions)
2) Mohammed (PBUH) never committed adultery of any kind, becuase he is the purist person who ever lived on earth, and there shall be no one like him
3) Mohammed (PBUH) married 9 yr old Aysha, becuase God ordered him to do so. The reason behind this is becuase she was to tell everything on his behalf when he died. And marriage is not always sex (if you think of women as sex machines, i dont know what to tell you
4) Mohammed (PBUH) was not the only messanger of God. There was about 500 messangers in total, and the Quran mentions about 250 of them. Mohammed (PBUH) did have miracles. FOR EXAMPLE multiplying food, and water for the thirsty and hungry, curing some diseased people. Traveling for Mecca to Jerusalem in one night, and going up to heaven. And the Greatest one of all is the Holy Quran (read some tru verses of the Quran, and you would know what I mean)
5) God the great sometimes ordered Mohammed to do things, that only God knew the reasons behind it
Next time, post questions only if you are confused about something. and let it be in good manners. Stop attacking Islam, and get a life plz
2006-10-18 06:56:21 · answer #4 · answered by AG 4 · 6⤊ 4⤋
BULLSHIT...
first give the references of the SURAH n QURAN..
u'll prove urself wrong kiddo...
Answers:
1:who believes in the bible??. its been changes soooo many times thats its impossible to tell wuts true in it.... the concept of trinity wasnt in the bible till some 200 yrs or more after God took up jesus... so basically Bible isnt wut i call "the truth".. Muhammad (pbuh) believed in wut JESUS SAID n NOT in which the "man made bible" says!! n its the bible that says the jesus was son of God.. n bibles been tempered with!!!!! so its not the truth!
2: hellooo?? where did u get this info.. i'm hearin this for the first time.. kiddo.. give some references..
his slave Zaid had family problems with his wife (who was actually muhammads cousin)n he divorced his wife n then the prophet married her.. wuts wrong in it?? cant a divorcee marry again?????
3: wrong,... from the ahadeeth i.. its been proved that Ayesha had reached the age of puberty n she was 14 when he married her...
4: WRONG again!!!.. Quran has sura (chapters).. n QURAN is the WORD OF GOD.. Muhammad (pbuh) has no saying in the Quran.. well kiddo.. there r many miracles in the Quran .. one abt Muhammad (Pbuh) goin to the heavens in one night on a horse called BURRAQ.. its in the Quran.. .. but the miracle of islam is QURAN.. not a word of it has been changed.. n nobody can challenge this miracle... since its open to all of u !!!!
5:now who the hell r u talkin abt?? which baby??? stop posting bullshit..
if u think u know soooooo much abt islam.. wut abt giving us ur references with the surah no etc.. n then we'll simply open the Quran n PROVE U WRONG!!!
kiddo its abt time... u stop posting crap n get a life !!!
2006-10-18 07:01:07 · answer #5 · answered by Apple 4 · 5⤊ 4⤋
I think u r a complete idiot, if u yrself cannot make any comment or if u don't know about Islam then plz just shut yr mouth!
1.Yes surely Hz Isa was risen to heaven till the day of ressurection. Allah sent another person instead of Jesus.
3.Hz Muhammad (pbuh) married Hz Aishah when she was 9 when her father Hz Abu Bakr insisted ;to strenghten ties between them.
4.Muhammad (pbuh) was in this world to preach Islam and NOT TO PERFORM MIRACLES.
plz don't poke yr nose in other religions if u don't know about them, it would be enough for u to handle yrs. if u're not a muslim stay away from such matters.
Read the Holy Quran if u want to know ANYTHING about Islam.the questions which I have not answered are non-existent so think 1000...million...billion times before u criticize another religion!!
2006-10-18 06:59:45 · answer #6 · answered by U know who 3 · 5⤊ 4⤋
1- he is prophet and if u read the qur'an u will know .. its the same thing that the stories of prophets are mention in the qur'an .. how he will know if the god didnt tell him ?
2- he never slept with the wife of his slave !! "give me abreak why dont u site ur false fact in a good site or at least islamic site "
3- she was 9 and it was in the past age so its normal to marry a young women and she wasnt child coz it had the period "adult" ..its about culuter .
4- who told u ?? the qur'an is the miracle of Arabs coz no ONE can write a single ayah of it.. its amazing words.. if u can read arabic and read qur'an u will know what i am talking about .. and also the moon get divide into two by the power of god .. there is alot of miracles of prophets and ppl still doesn't believe isn't enough.
5- i don't know about this its false fact that hater tells as usual.. could u source?
how about learning islam from this site then u can ask us :
http://islamtomorrow.com/
2006-10-18 06:57:13 · answer #7 · answered by Alone 4 · 5⤊ 4⤋
You got it all wrong some how GOD Laws are made of three Books: The Old Testament, The new Testament and Quran as a conclusion all originated from the middle east. How can you understand GOD LAWS with out reading GOD Conclusion?
2006-10-18 06:44:50 · answer #8 · answered by Anonymous · 5⤊ 4⤋
1) Jesus never said in the Bible "I'm God" or "worship me"
Saying my father means the same thing when Jacob and David said that God is thier father..Adam was God's son in the bible..so God's son is not like your son to you..And we believe that your Bible is corrupted so it doesn't amtter for us what is written there as the words of God were mixed with the words of petr and Paul and with the historicians.
2)"His slave" was called Zaid Ibn Haritha and he wasn't his slave but he was adopted by the prophet PBUH..his wife Zaynab Bint Jahsh didn't want to continue with him and wanted divorce so Allah "God" ordered the prophet to marry her for two reasons:
1.To prove for Arabs that they can marry the divorced and widowed of their adopted children as adoption in Islam doesn't result in inheritage or prohibits marrying their sisters....etc.
2)To compensate Zaynab for her unhappy marriage.
3) For mother Ayesha see this link:http://www.answering-christianity.com/aisha.htm
read it if you really want an answer not only mocking.
4)The miracles? they are many..see this too:http://www.sunnah.org/history/miracles_of_Prophet.htm
5) Never happened .. may be you mis understood the HADITH not surah as I know my Qur'an well..why didn't you post the Hadith..
And by the way the links you gave show how ignorant the publishers of those sites are because any average Muslim can respond to those unworthy accusations.
2006-10-18 07:34:06 · answer #9 · answered by mido 4 · 4⤊ 3⤋
In the name of Allah the most gracious the most mercifull
Asalm-o-alikum ( even if u r non- muslim)
Listen my dear friend u don't know any thing about prophet Muhammed (piece be upon him) life watever our Prophet has done there is reason behind it and he only do those things which Allah had told him
and if u want 2 know about prophet Muhammed (peice be upon him and islam check out these websites www.islam.com
www.islamtomorrow.com
www.islamboard.com
1st check these website then ask a stupid question understand
2006-10-18 07:52:49 · answer #10 · answered by Anonymous · 2⤊ 4⤋
if you say all of these things are in the quran (by the way a sura is a chapter in the quran and not a seperate book so already i doubt you as a source) then please leave citations and possibly someone could answer you
2006-10-18 07:17:00 · answer #11 · answered by Submission 3 · 4⤊ 3⤋