Can anyone tell me one way that America benifits from illegal immigration ?

Question

Must be realistic, and proven .

Show source, to back up your cliam to please, and NO AZTLAN.

Carol R - That just costs the tax payers more money, and having a class room with children speaking English or Spanish, disrupts the class room, and forces teacher to move at a slower pace.

Kool_rock - I have a source for you, http://www.alternet.org/story/34768/.

This talks about what happens when you mix Mexico, America,immigration, and freetrade togeather.

howdoyou k - link showed me things that Americans do not want . Interesting post but just backs up every reason to deport them.

glenn - You need to learn to seperate immigrants, from illegal immigrants. Other then that your comments don't really deserve a responce.

Julio Cesar C - You are wrong, the money saved in labor is pocketed by the employer. To force employers to pay a living wage, would help balance the economy.

Sketch - No , this country was not founded on illegal immigrants. It was founded on the desire to build a nation, not on exploiting one. Illegal immigrants are not trying to be part of America. Don't confuse them.

Answer 1

As far as I can tell, there is not even 1. Unless you are a crooked employer. By the time it all filters down to the tax payer, we all loose!

Answer 2

Rich Americans hire illegal aliens at a lower cost than they spend if they hire U.S. citizens because they save on payroll taxes and the fact that illegal immigrants usually will do the work for cheaper. So, the answer to your question of how does "America" benefit- it doesn't as a society, but a few Americans do as individuals.

Guess what, those few Americans that do benefit, contribute much more to the political parties than those Americans that don't benefit. The result is political parties that say they are doing something about illegal immigration so people will vote for them. They however, do nothing significant.

Answer 3

I like your points in this question/comment. Actually, I take back my last comment to your most current question. I just have never heard that STD's or diseases spread from illegals in our country and in the contrary, those things spread through carelessness and ignorance, but that's my opinion and it's based on my lack of ever catching an STD or being part of an epidemic.

Answer 4

The obvious. Cleaper labor & the ability to avoid any paperwork reguarding employees. Pay per day of manual labor. There is no need ror any source for that....

The disadvantages is that usa is slowly being consumed by a literal mexican takeover of america. Askign how? What would happen if half of americas population one day spoke spanish only.

While there are pros, those can be realised once mexico stands up and builds manufacturing infrastructure in mexico to create china like paying jobs for the manufacturing china currently does. The cons are slow and inevidable due to birth rates. The type of cons we wont notice untill its too late.

Answer 5

People will tell you that illegal immigrants are willing to do tough jobs. So what? Anyone is willing to do tough jobs if the pay is reasonable. The fact that illegals work for little pay and then send money to Mexico hurts our economy more than it helps it.

"Carol R", how many American teachers do you think speak Spanish? Soon they will be REQUIRED to learn spanish because immigrants from Mexico are too lazy to learn English.

"howdoyou k", I will gladly pay more for lettuce is if means less illegals because that means that healthcare will be cheaper because there won't be illegals who get healthcare for free. Also, less gangs and crime, and less trashy neighborhoods. I would even give up vegetables completely if it meant no illegals.

It's pathetic that you are proud of the fact that illegals work crappy jobs for low pay. That's like being proud of licking feces off someone's shoe.

Answer 6

Yes ... the crime rate goes up... the housing of citizens becomes harder.... taxes are increased or the deficit goes up... The minimum wage stays low..... overcrowding in schools goes up...
we will obtain a new official language in America... drug use goes up.... jobs are lost.... salaries go down... hell MTV already has a channel for them, seriously its called MTV tr3es
(MTV 3 basically). yeah its great!!!!!!!!!

Answer 7

Well the schools or the Teacher's Unions. More kids = more tax funding = job security

Answer 8

My answer is realistic and doesn't need proving, it is the truth.....

America benefits by the deportation of illegal aliens.... it reduces crime and our cost of living. It benfits society in the USA enormously in every way imaginable.....

YES, DEPORTATION of ILLEGAL ALIENS is a great BENEFIT to Americans.

Answer 9

Yes it is great. The rude mexicans kept my wife and daughters from working in vegetable and fruit packing factories. They harassed them, licked their lunch and said white women belong in the home and their husbands make enough money.
They keep teen agers from being able to get summer work because they pick on them and parents don't trust them around their kids.
This happened both in oregon and arizona.

Answer 10

Yes, one thing that comes to mind is how they clog up our health care system. with no insurance, hospitals still have to treat these criminals and unfortunately, receive no reimbursement for services.. After this happens over and over again, the hospital eventualy has to close down. Employees are now laid off, receive unemployment benifits and now they can stay home and watch Oprah. Sweet!!!