Catholics always have a dead Jesus on the cross. I think I know why. Do you think this explanation has merit

Question

Here's why I think Catholics like to portray Jesus as dead on the cross:

Pilate "found no fault" with Jesus and was going to release him.

To get Jesus crucified, the High Priest of Israel said "We have no king but Caesar".

Because the priest had the authority to bestow the office of "king", the office did actaully change hands.

Pilate (the authorized representative of Rome) then transfered the title to Jesus.

Because this is the accusation for which he was crucified, if He wasn't guilty of the charge, he wouldn't have been put to death.

OK, Jesus died. If Jesus rose from the dead, the living Jesus retains the Title "The King of the Jews".

If Jesus remained dead, the Title reverts back to Caesar who had been given the office of "King of the Jews" by the High Priest.

Since the Roman Empire morphed into the Roman Catholic church, their only claim to their authority derives from Jesus staying dead following the crucifiction.

The resurrection nullifies it.

Answer 1

That sounds very feasible! The catholics indeed want Jesus dead, so they can enthrone their god, the pope. The cross should be empty, for he is risen, proving that HE IS GOD!!!

Answer 2

the Resurrection does not nullify anything - rather, it solodifies everything. Yes, Jesus, my Lord and Saviour rose from the dead - Saving me. However, He would not have had to do that if i was not a sinner. He would not have had to suffer had we not been sinners.
The cross is a reminder to all of us who live in the modern world of the sacrifice our Lord & Saviour gave for us - to help us whenever we feel the "poor pity me's" coming on.

The basic foundation of the Roman Catholic Church -- Christ has died, Christ is Risen, Christ will come again.

Answer 3

Catholics have always sculpted Jesus in pain on the cross dying for our sins. i don't think that he was meant to be Dead. it is a reminder of what our king and savior went thru and experienced to save us from our sins and give us the choice in final destiny. the only reason why it is seen in more catholic churches than others, is because most churches feel it is too graphic. i don't really see any need in looking into it much more than that. i feel that the catholics made a just decision in how exactly they wanted to remember every time they came to church, just how much of a blessing Jesus is to all who know him.

Answer 4

Catholic's believe in Jesus' death and Resurrection. What you have to understand is that the cross by itself does not retain redeeming powers to save. It was the One cricified on that cross that retains redeeming powers to save.

The fact that the Roman Empire eventually embraced Christianity proves that God's love is more powerful than the largest political, economic, and miliatary influence mankind had produced up to that point in time.

Answer 5

Well, think about this--In the Old Testament when God told Moses to attach the bronze serpents to the pole in the middle of camp and have the people that had been bitten by the snakes that were in their camp look at the serpents on the pole and if they did not look at the serpent on the pole THEY WOULD DIE. Now, did God say to put the serpent on the pole--then take it down , then, everybody look at the pole? No they must look at the serpent on the pole. The same sacrifice that took place back then (Jesus) applies to us NOW , at our death-- so it needs to be a current reminder.

Answer 6

Christianity centers os salvation, and salvation got here by ability of the sacrifice of Jesus on the flow. subsequently,clone of Jesus on the flow. there have been no longer Satanists in the sixth century. tutor data otherwise. And if this has to do with something Constantine did, why does it in difficulty-free words seem three hundred years later? how do you settle on which dots to connect? in basic terms googled "bent flow" to ensure out what you're speaking about, and that i visit't on the instantaneous locate something it is no longer on a conspiracy idea or anti-Catholic website. Piers Compton is any such minor author he doesn't seem on Wikipedia. in basic terms because you ahve a e book doesn't advise you comprehend what you're speaking about. also, you're patently copying somebody else's rant. I also discovered THAT Googling. try questioning for your self.

Answer 7

However, the words spoken during every Catholic mass include

"...he suffered, died, and was buried. On the third day he rose again, in fulfillment of the scriptures..."

Interesting theory, but if Jesus never died, there would be no sacrifice, and the covenant would not be as it is with EVERY Christian Church.

Peace

Answer 8

If you are going to try to think up reasons behind other faith's symbols, you might at least check to see what that faith itself thinks about it. Most of what we Protestants think about Catholic symbols is wrong.

Answer 9

We do beleive in the resurrection. We emphasize the cross because without it we are lost. Without His death there would be no salvation no resurrection. It is also to remind us of the cost of our sins.

Answer 10

I think it is to remind them of the sacrifice He paid.