How can we be sure that schizophrenia is a mental disorder and that "hearing God" is not?

Answer 1

Schizophrenics usually know they are mental, those who hear God don't. Now who is better off?

Answer 2

Well, anyone that hears God speaking to them has schizophrenia and need to be hospitalized. There is no God that speaks to people, and it is only a form of mental illness if someone hears voices. They can become insane and do things harmful to others because they believe that 'God' told them to do so.

Answer 3

Shouldn't "hearing God" be tested by others before accepting the information?

Test criteria would be:
- Does it line up with what is written in the bible?
- Does it make sense to more experienced believers?

Couldn't there be many reasons why a message claimed to be from God is not, like wishful thinking, trying to get recognition... ?

Answer 4

Because those who claim to be hearing god have the symptoms of schizophrenia. Trying to justify god's existence is a waste of time.

Notmel: many schizophrenics do not realize there is something wrong with them, they believe it is a part of them.

Answer 5

it rather is an truthfully illness requiring truthfully therapy. no longer comparable to some so-called medium announcing they might refer to lifeless human beings. See notes under: "what's schizophrenia? Schizophrenia is a persistent, intense, and disabling thoughts illness that has affected human beings for the era of historic previous. a pair of million p.c. of human beings have this ailment.a million those with the illness might pay attention voices different human beings do no longer pay attention. they might have self belief different everybody is analyzing their minds, controlling their thoughts, or plotting to wreck them. this might terrify those with the ailment and lead them to withdrawn or rather agitated. those with schizophrenia won't make sense whilst they communicate. they might take a seat for hours devoid of moving or conversing. each and every now and then those with schizophrenia look completely great till they communicate approximately what they're rather thinking. families and society are plagued by ability of schizophrenia too. lots of those with schizophrenia have undertaking conserving a activity or taking good care of themselves, so as that they have confidence in others for help. therapy helps relieve many indicators of schizophrenia, yet maximum people who've the illness preserve indicators for the era of their lives. even with the undeniable fact that, lots of those with schizophrenia can lead worthwhile and important lives of their communities. Researchers are coming up greater effectual drugs and utilising new learn kit to comprehend the motives of schizophrenia. interior the destiny years, this artwork might help preclude and greater advantageous cope with the ailment."

Answer 6

Things are really blurry.
Some of the schizophrenics might actually be possessed by demons, while many of those think they are actually hearing God are just self-suggesting.

Answer 7

There is a spirit of god in everyone includeing people that hear things, some of those words they hear may very well be from god. for gods word is within all of us, if we will but listen,

Answer 8

Humans do have telepathic and empathic ability. But we
block it out because of our senses protecting our nervous
system.
Bipolarity is due to the two opposing magnetic forces. One coming from the Source of Life. The other going back to it.
Whenp[eople lose mental control, they start getting pulled by these 2 forces, creating irregular mood swings.
Science will put all together one day. You'll see.

Answer 9

Both are mental disorders.

Answer 10

because believers is Jesus Christ don't exhibit the symptoms of someone with a mental disorder. If you took them to a doctor they wouldn't diagnose it that way. The beleivers I have known have been very rational in thought, actions, etc. They just don't match up.