How will it be possible for us rationalists to discuss reincarnation?

Question

If we understand that a person loses, beyond the five senses, the consciousness? One only vegetates and when one dies, all the information in the brain is destroyed.
What would be the human illusionism that makes us believe in spirits, souls, saints and other abstracts that are not only based on DNA and RNA genetics (formed by billions of chemical bases) in the parents, passed on to their children?

Answer 1

Problem solved.... There is no such thing, just salvation and eternal life. praise the Lord!! Eternal damnation for those who refused the free gift of that salvation by rejecting Jesus as their savior. Just eternal torment for them...

Revelation 20:10 And the devil that deceived them was cast into the lake of fire and brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are, and shall be tormented day and night for ever and ever.

Answer 2

The theory of rebirth should be understood on the basis of our understanding of the nature of causality. Because according to Buddhism every event must have preceding causes and conditions. Therefore, even a single cognitive event; say an instance of consciousness or mind, must have causes and conditions.

And so, through this process we can trace the beginning-less continuum to the consciousness . And once we are able to develop that kind of understanding of the causal process than the theory of rebirth develops naturally on the basis of that kind of causal understanding.

In Buddhism there is the mind you're primarily talking about and then the subtle mind. The mind you are talking about is dependant on the physical body as you describe and thus ends when the body dies and can be changed by changes in the body when alive.

Answer 3

Evolutionary Track

Aside from the occasional trysts with fate and the serendipitous encounters with fortune, I'd say that I have stayed pretty much on the same path as most humans. It seems that my destiny may be aligned with that of most mortals, who by the way, during my latest journey, I had learned much from. What I hope they have learned from me is the sanctity of Love, Understanding, Good Will and of course, the most difficult for those of flesh and blood - Forgiveness.

As it is with most of my stays here, I'm not in the position to criticize nor challenge although what I see at times provides me impetus to offer what I'd been given - Reason. Just as I had written not so long ago:

I have Reason, I have Rhyme

Pondering my thoughts,

Throughout the eons of time

Many times we are posed a question, so simple yet the most difficult to answer: Why am I here? Ah, because you belong. Simple enough an answer and it really needs no further explanation . . .

You know, I rely on you as much as you rely on me and the symbiotic nature of our relationship provides the universe with balance, although at times, it may not appear to be so . . .

Life to me, an open book

with each page, I learn something new

Yet, I await the final

the most revealing clue

Perhaps, when our fates are decided, would we learn the truth . . . eternity it beckons, so I had heard as I stood sentry-like against the winds of time . . .

Far in the distance, perhaps another void

a place where my existence

can never be destroyed

Ricky J. Fico

Answer 4

There's no rational discussion that includes reincarnation or life after death. The only thing you can revert to is allowing others to think what they want, based on the principle that all knowledge is not available. However, if you try looking for evidence for immortality, you'll come up wanting.

Answer 5

You can discuss anything you want hypothetically, and who knows? You just might run across some stray fact or bit of evidence that points to the possibility that this isn't all there is.

Hey. It's a big universe! The point is, if you don't look, you'll never know.

Answer 6

Uh, maybe because we want to believe that we will be reunited with people we care about someday? Maybe because it's impossible to intellectually or emotionally grasp the concept of one's own consciousness ceasing to exist? Maybe because we don't want our consciousness to cease to exist?

Rational thinking is a valuable tool. But it's not the only way to understand the world. There could be aspects to life which we can't perceive with our five senses. There could be aspects to our existence which are beyond rational comprehension. To deny that possibility is in itself irrational.

Answer 7

When there is any valid evidence for it.

There is much we can talk about concerning why people believe things that aren't true. There are various insecurities that humans have that are easily played upon by religious people. We have been emotional animals far longer than rational ones, so those types of tactics work.

Answer 8

OK, discuss it rationally. But first, you need some evidence, established through a controlled, repeatable, peer reviewed experiment that shows there is a likelihood the phenomenon exists in the first place.

I'm afraid pointing at a book will not count.

Off you go.

Answer 9

in accordance to Vedic Literatures we are actually not this physique however the Soul. At death the physique loses understanding and not the soul. understanding is infact the symptom of the soul. in simple terms because of the fact Soul is utilising this cutting-edge physique to do all events, would not advise that Soul would not have its own physique to do the comparable. in simple terms like a automobile driving force may be utilising automobile to bypass, yet whilst the automobile breaks down, the driving force can nevertheless flow. further soul has the thank you to maintain memory too... yet whilst it takes a clean physique and starts off utilising that innovations for memory, the previous memory isn't downloaded into that innovations. nevertheless it quite is seen that in the time of Hypnotic state or in subconscious physique state or in objectives, this memory may be tapped. All RNA, DNA remains this physique. you're able to desire to come to the platform of Soul to communicate reincarnation.

Answer 10

the nature of electricity is one that once created cannot be destroied but only dispersed.

the human body runs off of electricity especially the brain.

this electricity has to go somewhere when the body breaks down.

so the existence of a soul is simply a natural phenomina of electricity being able to gather without dispersing.

light and electricity are capable of holding a memory and pattern. and human memory is really just a pattern of electrical impulses.