what is the cost of giving all illegals amnesty as opposed to putting real penalties on those who hire like?

Question

huge fines'''like we have for drunk driving,even more,,,,,and watching them go back to where they came from,,,,,which way would cost this country more and be better for buisness in general my keyboard has punction sorry

no punctuation

Answer 1

Are you a legal citizen? You appear kind of uneducated and your writing is poor, i.e. "my keyboard has punction", whatever that meant. This category needs real questions, not just whiners.

Answer 2

I think I understand what you are trying to say.
Yes it would make sense to penalize those who hire illegals and that would eventually make them go away. But for that you will need to establish an infrastructure to check the legality of a prospective employee.Till that time you cannot hold the employer responsible.
You have to plug all holes.
No medical for illegals ( On a a reasonable note give them medical aid and then drop them off at the nearest border.
No special education for illegals.
No automatic citizenship for anchor babies.
If an illegal becomes legal through marriage huge penalties of tax and other penalties. He /she would not pay all that and leave the country.
Anybody caught without real id and cannot prove his status ,escort them to the border and many more holes to be plugged.
This is not simple problem though solution is simple if only the Govt wants to do something.

Answer 3

I don't understand your question. If you are asking if it will be a net loss to tax payers if people are deported rather than given amnesty, no it will not. Los Angeles County alone spends $1 billion a year on benefits to illegal immigrants, and were they legal they would not only be entitled to more benefits, they would be entitled to bring in more family who could bring in more.... and so forth.

The problem needs to be stopped. Even if you only say 'going forward' that means enforcing at school enrollment, hospitals (after medical treatment) and consciously ASKING instead of purposely 'not asking' immigration status when people apply for benefits of any kind. And yes it means cracking down on employers, but THAT requires creating an employee database that I understand is years away.

However, how many times have you heard the argument that someone came, even giving up a better job, to build a better life for their children? It is our EDUCATION that is the biggest draw, as it is having to educate illegal aliens and their children that is the biggest cost to us - not only from the point of view of money, but from the point of view of a degraded education for our own children.

Answer 4

I saw a site the other day that said it would cost the federal budget 29 million dollars about 7700.00 per illegal family to give them amnesty ans right now its costing us 10 million dollars in the federal budget to have them here. Why more to give amnesty because think of all the things we will have to change and give them also they will still truly only contribute back to the economy only about fraction of what legal families pay in taxes because more than likely they will still work under the table for cheaper wages. Therefore in this case its not cheaper to keep em

Answer 5

How can you even consider giving legal status to a group of people who have already shown a contempt for our legal system and laws? They are already criminals and statistically are in the group most likely to commit other crimes. Why would you want to increase the number of criminals in this country?

Yes, employers should be given huge fines, enough that it could put them out of business to be causght hiring illegal people.

Answer 6

financial consideration is only a part of the problem with illegal immigrants.... it is what would happen to the culture of our country - life as we know it would be over. It is not fair for the legacy of American children to be a third world cesspool!

Answer 7

all this illegal alien crap is a cover up for the lack of solving the national security issue.