When will the 'Death Stampedes' in Mecca become to great to make Hajj obligation practical for most Muslims?

Question

Thosands of pilgrims are trampled to death in Mecca every year, and with global population growth, the death trends grows greater and greater every year.

The irony is, Muslims who are trampled to death, are killed in the most insulting way for Muslims (soles of the shoe are greatest insult). Because silly Allah supposedly controls all things, this must mean that Allah wills these Muslims to be murdered, in Islam's holiest place by the most insulting means. If Allah exists (of course he doesnt), we can only conclude that he hates Muslims.

In anycase, world population, for all religions and cultures, is contantly growing, thus, its impossible for the insane Hajj obligation to be something Muslims can perform in the future. Its only a matter of time till populations are so high, that even if a man puts in his Hajj request at birth, the logistics will deny him the possiblity.

What date do you think this critical mass will be achieved?

Answer 1

Once a really important Muslim figure dies on their Hajj in the "Mecca Stampede"

Answer 2

The fact is that u seem to be bugged up by some Muslim i guess. Thats y askin such a ques honey..But lemme tell u one thing, the death stampedes happen coz of lack of infrastructure and not becoz its the fault in Islam. Try to talk like a literate. The most logical things are found in Islam. For everything there lies an explanation. Pointing towards a religion by some crazy fella like u doesnt mean that the religion is bad or u have proved ur point. U only tryin to get out of ur frustration. Islam preaches respect for all religions and so does every religion as per my knowledge. Seems like either u dont believe in God or u have been dominated by satan greatly. But in any case i wud suggest u to read first about anything before u draw inference on it. U seem to be a looser to me. Good luck in your life ahead.

Answer 3

Strange how one takes so much time and effort to concentrate on such a silly matter.

Thousands don't die, it's never been that dramatic.

The Saudi government is generating more ideas to sustain the safety of believers. Most recently they constructed a second level around the three pillars for stoning, and are looking into more ways to enhance safety.

Soles do not bother me, so it must not really be a Muslim thing.

Murder is when one willfully takes the life of another. Why would someone murder another while he's concentrating so hard on his relationship with his Creator?

Creativity and ingenuity are two of man's greatest possessions. We've always had it, and it's not something that we're likely to lose anytime soon. Do you not think that if we can come up with more ways for the earth to handle the human population, that we cannot conceive of a way to handle worshipping pilgrims in a desert city?

Answer 4

Without even looking at any of the information involved I'm guessing that it's because the hard-core followers of both sides hate each others' guts. Much like the Protestans and Catholics of Northern Ireland in days gone by.... ...

Answer 5

The real question is why are you so focused on your hate campaign against all Muslims?

Why are you such a hater?

Answer 6

i would love to die while performing Hajj. those who do go straight to paradise as pilgrimage washes away your past sins.

alhamdu lellah.