why does Plato say God's desire doesn't MAKE a thing good or bad. Rather, God first KNOWS that a thing is good

Question

i know people are getting upset that i ask this question alot but bear with me i really want an answer.

Answer 1

Read Genesis?
In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth and all that are in them. EVERYTHING.
SO.......AND GOD SAY ALL THAT HE MADE AND BEHOLD IT WAS VERYYYYYYY GOOD.
*SIN/DEATH/BAD STUFF DIDNOT MULTIPLY/START UNTIL FREEWILL/SIN ENTERED INTO THE WORLD.
*GODS WORD HOLDS THE ANSWERS TO YOUR QUESTIONS ABSOLUTELY. -LIVE4TRUTH=]

Answer 2

To decide whether a thing is good or bad you must experience it from both sides and decide in your own subjective reality how you would like to label it. To me good and bad are two sides of the same spectrum (like east and west), and you cannot experience one without the other (nor can you get to one by going through the other - you cant travel east and ever expect to find west - that's just a point of view from where you started), so they each hold equal value. At this point it is up to you to decide. As far as god is concerned, whatever you believe god to be, you have the freedom of choice given to you by that god to decide for yourself - what else is choice for? The answer was left up to you to decide, not to believe what someone or something says.

Answer 3

because he doesn't know what he is talking about. and he will lead you astray. ask the Father instead.