why don't muslims sing "vande mataram"?

Answer 1

Their religion tells them to care about Islam only..no love for the country they live in, no love for those who dont follow their faith

Indian muslims are mainly those hindus whose forefathers were converted by sword or prize...and they have forgotten that Mother India is giving them livelyhood food and shelter

Answer 2

i'm an Indian first ,a Hindu secondly..... I thoroughly comply with you... at present the muslim community is concentrated as anti-nationalistic.......And to function to the hearth the Islamists are issuing fatwas after fatwas......to that end detiroirating the priority...the final non muslim individual in INDIA seems on the muslim community as terrorists... So i've got self belief its extreme time the Indian knowledgeable and nationluvr muslims could desire to upward thrust above the voices of Islamists and sing the VANDE MATARAM ,defy the unwell regulations of Islamists who're seperating the muslim community and ending the secularism 4 wich India replace into nicely-conventional on account that situations immemmorial........ I pray tht all Indian muslims connect hands with your fellow us of a adult men,be they hindus,Christian,sikhs,buddhists and so on and rize above communal tensions! to that end makin INDIA what it replace into interior the previous =UNITED! SING VANDE MATARAM!!!! JAI HIND

Answer 3

To be precise this song if you have ever gone through , was written in Bangali and for a book called Anandmath.Later few sanskrit stanzas were added with 'some intention'

These stanzas are in praise of goddess Durga and other dieties.

Now dont you think honestly that it will be unfair of you to force people of other religion to sing it ?

Some more points can also be kept in mind. There is no mention of the NATION in whole of the song. So you can see it is the only national song which does not mention the name of its own nation.

Moreover 99 percent of whole Indian population can not sing it and you blame muslims only for not singing it.

They can still sing it if muslims are convinced that the whole song does not mention of POOJA of any hindu diety or POOJA of
motherland. Which you people have failed.

Be sensible and dont corner or alienate the muslims from the mainstream of the country. You are in fact causing irreperable harm to the motherland.

I humbly request such people to come together and make our country proud.

Vande matram.....[ ma tujhe salaam ]

Answer 4

It not just that "Vande Mataram" they refuse to sing.
They are not allowed to be open minded even in a multi- culture nation.
They don't respect anything that is not theirs if they live in a non-Sharia country.
Pray for them. They may change in 50 years!

Answer 5

LOVE OF COUNTRY IS THE SECOND MOST IMPORTANT THING TAUGHT IN ISLAM....NOW WHY THEY DON'T SING VANDE MATRAM' ITS BECAUSE OF ITS MEANING...WHICH INDICATES WORSHIPPING THE COUNTRY AS GODDESS...WHICH IS AGAINST BASIC TENETS OF ISLAM WHICH TEACHES THERE IS NO GOD BUT ONE...ALLAH' ALMIGHTY....THERE HAS BEEN SCORES OF MUSLIMS WHO HAVE LAID DOWN THEIR LIVES IN WAR AGAINST PAKISTAN...ABDUL HAMEED FOR ONE....ABOUT WHOM WE ARE TOLD IN SCHOOLS EVEN TODAY...WE SHOULD TRY TO ANSWER THE QUESTIONS WITHOUT PREJUDICES AND BIASES...AND KEEP THE AMBIANCE CLEAN IN YAHOO ANSWERS FOR THE BENEFIT OF ALL'...BY SAYING VANDE MATRAM YOU DON'T BECOME A PATRIOT...AND YOU DON'T BECOME ANTI NATIONAL IF YOU DON'T...

Answer 6

All they care for is for Misinterpretations by their religious heads who are more bothered about quran and its antique rules, care nothing for the nation .
All they want to get is the maximum mileage from the cheap politics adapted by congress party and its allies ,who try to appease them can even lick their feet or anything to acheive their support.

Answer 7

They give more importance to the words than their essence

Answer 8

theres a controversy going about this,,,

Answer 9

its all politics!