Which 1 do you think is better- Home schooling or school?

Question

also tell me WHY

I mean, in terms of Indian education. My daughter who is currently in class8 says she wants do her 9th year at home with help from tutors.

Answer 1

I don't know what schools are like in India and I'm sure most of us in here don't. I also don't think one is necessarily better than another. While I've chosen to homeschool, I know some people who should definitely not homeschool.

Homeschooling is better if you think the school environment is not one where you want your child to be, for whatever reason, and if you are willing to take it on and do what you need to. Public school is better if you are not willing to do what you need to.

It might be better to find an Indian homeschooling support group and get more information that way. Any comments made about socialization and clubs refer to Western schools and may have no relevance to your situation. Somebody who knows how things are where you live will be able to provide you with much better information. Maybe the links on this site can help you:

http://homeschooling.gomilpitas.com/regional/India.htm

Answer 2

If a child does well in a regular school environment that is probably better for that child. Homeschooling is good only if it is done properly. That means that either the student or an adult ensures that the eduaction is complete. (some students are mature enough to do this for themselves.) Some times homeschooling fails when neither the parent or the student is interested in making sure the student gets a complete education. It is the parents responsiblity to make sure the student is learning and keeping up with the correct level of schoolwork. A parent can hire a tutor to do this. It is not the easy way out, but it is a good solution especially when there are problems at school. (problems at school can include the student becoming bored because the class is too slow.)

Answer 3

I think homeschooling is better because it is a one on one form of teaching that enables the student to florish if given the proper teaching and understanding. There should be structure and deadlines still just as a public or private school would have. There should be proper courses taken and records or course credits and grades kept so that she will have no problem getting into a college if she so decides to do. She should also be allowed to take the SAT and the ACT tests which are also important to getting into college. Homeschooling can be a very effective form of schooling that can produce a highly educated student if properly done. Definitely look into different companies and their different courses before deciding on a layout for your credits for her first year of high school. Remember that besides the basic math, English, history, and science there are other courses that are important in high school such as literature both English and British, a foreign language (usually two years of this), computer applications and typing, special interest courses (electives), and music (instrumental or voice). Good luck with your decision and the outcome.

Answer 4

I think it depends on the kid and what you mean better. As far as education goes, it is what the child makes of it. Homeschool children often do better, because they have devoted parents that make their entire life a learning experience. Regular schooling can be as educational if the child takes advantage of all that it has to offer and has parents that are also supportive. As far as socialization, home schoolers find other ways to socialize. THey are often involved in homeschooling groups, churches and other clubs and activities. Also, regular school is really starting to get scary. Not only all of the violence, but the push by peers for earlier sex, drugs, etc. Homeschoolers are less likely to feel the pressure of these issues. So all in all, I would have to say homeschooling is better.

Answer 5

I know nothing about Indian education ------- but in my community in the united states of Oregon I consider home-school to be the best choice for my family.

It is better because it works! My students self-teach and learn everything they need to know about how to study. They become good citizens.

Is isn't the *people* in home schooling that are better --- it is the process.

The educational system of home-school works better than a group type set-up because the student learns at a level and pace that is geared to their individual needs.

Barb

Answer 6

I think home schooling is better because if you have a job or do other things you can fit in your studying on the days you aren't doing anything. And if you are a young mother and still want to get an education and have to look after kids at home you have the option of studying at home.

Answer 7

You need to ask your child certain questions and talk to a school counselor first. Is your child having peer problems? Does she feel her classes are not challenging enough for her? How is she doing academically in school now? Is college in the future?
Are you as a parent ready to take on the responsibility of teaching and guiding him/her?
The successful home schoolers I know are usually college graduates who feel their local public schools do not offer quality education in a safe supportive environment.

You also mentioned tutors...will you be giving the teaching responsibilities over to tutors alone?

One is not better than the other there are good and bad public schools. You mentioned Indian school...please elaborate more on that. It is hard to compare if one does not know specifics.

I have a child who went to a very good local public school (grades 2-5). During his 4th grade we lived in China for 6 months. He missed four months of the school cycle but we prearranged home schooling from China with his school.
Most days we worked for no more than three hours and spent the rest exploring China. He returned to school with completed special projects, tests, lesson assignments in all subjects and homework...without any problems. In fact, he was well ahead of the class in math, science and reading.
It was a great experience for all of us but he loved seeing his friends again and was welcomed back to class with open arms.

My child is now in an excellent private prep school. I do not think I would want him anywhere else to prepare him for college. I do not think I could do a better job at home nor do I feel I am qualified. There is just so much knowledge to know at this stage.
For my family home schooling would be missing the rich academic, social and athletic opportunities available.

Home schooling, public schools, private schools...it all really depends on your child's situation and yours. Positives can be found in all.

Answer 8

It's hard to say. Homeschooling takes a lot more effort from the parents - and I don't just mean the teaching part. If the child is young and there are not many siblings near their age their social abilities may suffer. The parent would need to make sure their child is participating in activities outside of home school that involves children their age. (I.E. church, boy scouts, girl scouts, clubs..etc)

However, public school is becoming rather scary. Kids killing kids, bullies, too many kids then the teacher can teach...

It's hard to say honestly.

Answer 9

school because you child will be able to explore many different interests. if you home school her, she might not be able to recieve the highest degree of education available. Tutors can help, but they won't always know eveything a regular teacher knows. It can also become very expensive when you have to pay for these tutors. Trust me, I know. At school, your child will make new friends and be able to see how the real world works. By keeping your child inside, you are depriving her from having a chance to become successful and having a wide variety of friends. School can just be a rewarding experience for any child if they take advantage of what they are being offered.

Answer 10

There are advantages and disadvantages to both. Some examples.
Homeschooling:
Advantage: One-on-one contact with the student. You devote all your focus on their questions and problems. You may (or may not) move through material faster than compared to a classroom of students.
Disadvantage: Social interaction. It is very important for the student to learn teamwork with others. With no one to talk to and share frustration or triumph with is discouraging.

School is some what the opposite of home schooling. More social interaction, less one-on-one interaction from the teacher.

I would recommend school. They would have their peers to help them out and they would learn to make friends and teamwork.