Should ethnic minorities be confined to their own areas?

Question

i.e. chinese people to chinatown

Answer 1

People should be separated by political beliefs too!

Answer 2

No one should allow any form of getto's to be formed as it leads to diintigration of the country. We have ample evidence of many wars being fought due to such policies and the Muslim groups becoming almost like an internal war in Britain v/s the non Muslims shows us the dangers. Bradford Riots were also due to this reason. We have not learnt anything and in the name of Human Rights we are negating the rights of millions others. So in short no confinment to own area's. Spread out or get out

Answer 3

Integration perhaps is the single solution for Global World Peace,
therefore my answer is definitely no. If we do not integrate
globally there is little hope for peace. Integration always
takes into account the rules of supply and demand, in other
words, cost of property. If someone can pay the asker‘s
price, it does not matter who he is, provided he is cordial and
respects the local community. This applies for all ethnic groups
whether they are renting or purchasing. The laws of the country
will take care of the rest.

Answer 4

I don't think so. At least at the moment most people are integrating and getting along, although i admit there has been an increase in race hate crime, but if every one was segregated it would get ten times worse. It's good to live in a society where not everyone is the same and people can mix freely.

Answer 5

The way the Uk is going at the moment with all these imigrants taking over and demanding we change our ways to suit them, the normal christian raised BRIT will be the Minority! Mr Smith used to be the most common name in the phonebook! Not now its Mr Patel, Muhammad, Hussain etc etc!! God help this country if this trend continues!

Answer 6

2006 Derivation of Charles Mingus 1965 – based on Niemöller c.late 1940’s

One day they came and they took the Terrorists
And I said nothing because I was not a Terrorist
Then one day they came and they took the Arabs and the Asians
And I said nothing because I was not an Arab or an Asian
One day they came and they took the people of the Muslim faith
And I said nothing because I had no faith left
One day they bombed Afganistan, then Iraq, then the Lebanon (again)
And I said nothing because I was born in the West
Then one day they came and they took me
And I could say nothing because I was as guilty as they were
For not speaking out and saying that all men have a right to freedom
On any land
I was as guilty of genocide
As you
All of you
For you know when a man is free
And when to set him free from his slavery
So I charge you all with genocide
The same as I

Answer 7

Yeah! Let's clean up this country. The Irish say "Ireland for the Irish" - so let them go back there. Outlands (Staffordshire) for the outlandish, Rubery (Hereford & Worcestershire) for the rubbish, Foolow (Derbyshire) for the foolish, Boorley Green (Hampshire) for the boorish, Peckham (South London) for the peckish. I'll stop now.

Answer 8

Why sure!

Just make sure that their contribution to society is likewise confined. This includes, scientific research to treat and cure illnesses, engineering advances to preserve lives and property during natural disasters, and keep the earnings from companies raising the DOW index just to themselves.

Answer 9

No. I like going for a Chinese Take-Away. I wouldn't be allowed if we all had to stay in our own areas

Answer 10

And just what area of the North American Continent would you have Natives confined to? Which parts of our homelands would you give away to foreigners this time?

Answer 11

I think this happens anyway and groups tend to create their own areas rather than integrating. When this happens over large areas it can only be divisive and lead to problems, economic, social and political. 'Taking over' areas or gehttoising areas of towns and cities is counter-productive and governments need to look at why this is happening.