If Hadhrath Umar was correct when he denied the dying request of the Holy Prophet on the premise that...?

Question

... the 'Qur'an is sufficient for us' (Sahih al Bukhari Vol 7 hadith number 573) what will be the reward for accusing the Holy Prophet (saaws) of speaking nonsense?
(See Sahih al-Bukhari Vol 5 number 716)

Answer 1

no reward. u get hell

Answer 2

Now, I'm a Christian and learning about my brethren of the world, so please, bear with me as I am trying to understand you.

Do you mean that Hadhrath Umar was correct in denying the dying request of the Holy Prophet and that He (the Prophet) was not acknowledged by Hadhrath because of his belief on the Qur'án was far more important than in the Prophet?

Answer 3

many people have mistaken the story of aisha. and his other wives, his wives were a way of uniting the arab tribes, and aisha was at least 10 when married however it was customary in those days for a girl to be wed berfore the age of 8
and in regards to ur question i have never heard this hadith in my life it probalbly is a da3if hadith

Answer 4

who says he was correct what is in the book and what is the fact a lot of differances in my view when we dont confirm practically about any one how can we claim correct or non correct but he was not correct as per the tantra and divine law because he was alone life and that shows something wrong some where

Answer 5

It is narrated in Saheeh Bukhari and Muslim that Ibne Abbas narrated:

When the Holy Prophet was seriously ill, and all of us were around him, he opened his eyes and said, bring me pen and paper so that I may write something which shall always guide you and shall keep you on the Right Path and shall save you from being astray. Hearing these words from the lips of the Holy Prophet, Omar said, " Ur- Rajulo la -Yahjur” meaning this man was talking which makes no sense.”Hasbona Kitab Allah” The Book of God is sufficient for us.
This gave rise to a dispute among the companions. Some were of the opinion that as the Holy Prophet was to be obeyed at all times and under all circumstances a pen and paper should be provided to him, while some of them were on the side of Omar. The hot discussion on that point between the companions gave rise to noise and the Holy Prophet angrily told them to go away from his presence and leave him alone.”

EXPLANATION:

Let us consider the words of Rasulullah (s) he wanted to write a document "after which you will never go astray" - Rasulullah (s) clearly viewed this as a document that would protect the Ummah from misguidance that would save them in times of Fitnah. Hadhrath Umar's objection "The Qur'an is sufficient for us" would seem to suggest that the Qur'an was that all encompassing document that protects the faithful from fitnah.

Indeed the scripture of Allah covers all issues, but it is the Prophet of Allah who explains to us the details of the universal principles laid out in the Qur'an. For this reason, by its very nature the Qur'an alone without the Prophet's Sunnah is not sufficient to derive Islamic Law for all spheres of life. That is why Allah states in the Qur'an: Surah Nisa verse 65 "No by Allah they haven't believed until they make you a Judge in all their disputes." And that is why every decision of the Prophet (s) is binding upon us: Surah Hashr verse 7 "Whatever the Prophet gives you take it, whatever he prevents you from doing refrain from it."

If we analyze the Book of Allah, we see that Allah (swt) does not describe everything in detail. On the contrary the Qur'an establishes universal principles and general rules for all things, but as to the exact implication and methodology for how we are supposed to implement and practice those universal rules, this was left for Hadhrath Muhammad (s) to clarify both verbally and through his own practical example, i.e. his Sunnah. That is why the Book of Allah alone is not sufficient for the Muslims to comprehend Islam and derive Islamic Law. Hadhrath Muhammad (s) was sent to not only relay Allah (swt)'s Word, but to explain Allah's Book and its deep meanings to the people.

"...We have revealed to you the Remembrance so that you may explain to humankind that which has been revealed for them..." (The Holy Qur'an 16:44)

Accordingly, the Qur'an alone can never be enough, but must be accompanied by the Prophet's commands and exemplification. After all, the Prophet (s) was sent to a people who were living in the dark ages, most of whom were illiterate. And as the above verse shows they and the Muslims in general needed the Prophet (s) to clarify the verses of the Qur'an - that is why Muhammad's (s) mission was to relay and explain those actions through his Sunnah which provided a practical commentary on the Qur'anic verses. Thus, according to the Qur'an itself (e.g. "We have revealed to you the Remembrance so that you may explain to humankind that which has been revealed for them."), the Qur'an can NEVER be enough. If we read the Qur'an, it is evident that Allah (swt) chooses not to elaborate on crucial parts of the Deen, but leaves the Prophet [saw] to clarify the universal principles revealed in the Book. For example the Qur'an makes no reference on how to calculate Zakaat, It does not explain the Hajj rites, - even the first Pillar and cornerstone of Islam, Salaat (Prayer), is not explained in the Qur'an. Allah (swt) does not explain how you are to perform Salaat, how to pray, what to say when you are standing, or when you bend, or when you prostrate; do you sit down first or do you stand?

Thus, we can see clearly that Allah (swt) in His infinite Wisdom had intentionally ensured that the Qur'an is not sufficient in itself for people to derive Islamic Law, so that people would turn to the Prophet to explain the application of the universal principles contained in the Qur'an.

Answer 6

Well, I need to read this hadith to understand the content better.
Quran is source of religion knowlege for me.

There is no reward for accusing any muslim in Islam. It is kind of backbiting which is haram ( sin)

Answer 7

have a heart. Dont ask such questions on yahoo answer. Go to some learned person if you have any doubt. You see stupid people are giving stupid answer. ask forgiveness as these stupid people are already to be thrown in hell. why you wana join them.
God bless you.

Answer 8

The Quran attempts to explain the past.

The Bible tells the future in perfect detail, including this generation and exactly what will happen.

Does the Quran do that?

Answer 9

I do not know what you are talking about no way was mohammed holy he married to many women inclusing aisha at 6 years old that is not a holy man

Answer 10

The Bible is sufficient for me

Answer 11

matthew, are you Muslim?

in response to your question.... the people who make such accusations do it in ignorance