how thin is too thin?

Question

at what size do men consider a girl too thin and at what size is she too fat?

Calm down its just a question, i never said i cared what men think of me! its a general question

Answer 1

A real man only cares about the smile on his girls face and her happiness.

If the girl is miserable about her size then she is too fat/thin or does not have a true concept about herself.

A good man will instill confidence in the one he truly cares about.

Answer 2

size 6 or below is too thin (but not if it's your NATURAL body size). Size 20 + is too big because noone is naturally this size. To the person that said size 12 is too fat, what planet are you living on?! It's probably one of the most common sizes out there. Marilyn Monroe was a size 16 and I'm sure she looked way better than any size 12 your know, or whatever you size is aswell.

Answer 3

depends on the man, depends on the culture, depends on what is fashionable. In general a girl is too thin when she stops having periods. Too fat is when your organs are pushing each other aside, when you are getting health problems from it, when your legs rubs together whenever you walk to the extend that you get burn marks from it on your legs. Beauty is in the mind and a matter of taste, not size. cause that's what you want to hear, right? What do man consider a beautiful size for a girl? As long as a body is in proportion and there is a person in it happy with that body, that's a sign they have the right size.

Answer 4

Size 6 and 8 is too thin. Size 28 and above is too fat.

Answer 5

every girl is different, im 5'3 and weigh 7.5 stones, the doc rekons i am underweight, but im happy. it all depends on height, also too thin is not good, some celebs are so thin at the minute and look ill. what does it matter what a man thinks anyway? they will never be happy with the way a woman looks, all men want a size 8, big boobs, pert bum, and blonde hair on a woman and even then they will not be happy (sorry guys, im sure you are not all like that but most are)

Answer 6

Message to "Alex" - Size 12 is too fat??????????
That is an average size in the UK, and anyway, it always depends on the individual shape. I know some shorter, curvy size 12's and some taller thinner size 12's. I personally think that size 12 is perfect! You obviously think size 12 is fat. Its all a personal opinion. But what worries me is when people listen to opinions like yours, and they starve themselves and make themselves ill!
So Alex, before you make assumptions on a healthy size 12, being "too fat" - Think about the consequences.

Sorry Soph - Havent really answered your question there have I?

Answer 7

I'm pretty sure that no man finds bones attractive unless they're pretty well covered! And, at the other end of the scale (sorry about that) not many men are attracted to gross flab. I think the key word has to be 'shapely'. If a woman's too skinny or too fat to have shape, that's your answer.

Answer 8

Do you really mean that you are basing your body image on what a man thinks? Just any old man? Why? Why not just be the size you are most comfortable? Men usually prefer a woman who is comfortable in her own skin, whatever size that might be.

Answer 9

Depends on the man some like them fat some like them thin

Answer 10

whoever said 12 is too fat is an idiot!! most women in the uk on avarage is a size 16 bet u didnt know that!!!

too thin is when your not only resemble a concentration camp prisoner its when it starts to effect your whole persona